Reviews on NB Irish Stout?

[GA81]

Has anyone tried this one? Just ordered from NB. I have some Edinburgh yeast on hand so was thinking on using that instead or Irish yeast. I've seen mixed reviews. Is there anything I couldn't add to improve this extract? Thanks y'all!

 

[flars]

One of my favorites. Always used WY 1084. Great beer with WY 1084. At your own risk if you brew the first one with substitute ingredients. I've never used S-04.

 

[GA81]

Ok I won't tinker with this one! I will also go out and pick up some Irish yeast. Thanks for the info!