I have sampled one bottle so far. I tried it up against the batch we made last month. I still have a few gallons left. I bought The Pliny Packs from Farmhouse Brewing. Side by side they are really close. The real Pliny is just a little hoppier and a tad sweeter than ours...I think because we didn't hop our mash and we missed our FG by a couple points but I am surprised at how close they are though....my buddy and I brewed a 10 gallon batch about 6 weeks ago. I had never had the real deal until last week and hadn't tried them side by side until last night. So next time I'm gonna hop the mash and up the grain bill and see where that gets me.