• Please visit and share your knowledge at our sister communities:
  • If you have not, please join our official Homebrewing Facebook Group!

    Homebrewing Facebook Group

First time brew

Homebrew Talk

Help Support Homebrew Talk:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

builder59

Member
Joined
May 11, 2009
Messages
9
Reaction score
0
Location
Fenton MI
Should I have thrown away all of the sediment from my boil. I used grain and two bags of malt extract and hops, I had a lot of junk on the bottom when I transferred into my primary fermenter. Or should I have dumped everything in the primary?

Thank a lot.
Ron
 
There are three general schools of thought. One, just dump it all in there and let the primary sort it out. Two, pour it through a strainer so most the bigger crap gets filtered out. Three, stir the hell out of it at the end of cooling so the whirlpool causes all the crap to collect in the middle of the pot and then siphon from the outside edge and most of it gets left behind.

It's just a matter of preference how you do it, but it's generally accepted that some amount of break material getting into the primary is good for the ferment.
 
I normally try and filter out the stuff from the boil kettle so I do not have to do it later.

+1, in addition, the owner of my local brew store said to filter out and avoid the trub on the bottom of the kettle...He seemed to think it can produce off flavors, not sure about that, but it makes a cleaner fermentation.
 
Thank a lot. I was worried at first. I seen all the sediment and thought that it would only make it taste bad, then I started to think that the yeast needed something to eat, so I wasn't sure.

I have a spicket on the side near the bottom of my turkey fryer so it made easy transfer to my primary. I'm kegging right off the bat, so in 4 or 5 days I'll transfer and carbonate. I can't wait. I use Michigan Brewing Co. Makinac Pale Ale.
 
I've seen several of the sages (YooperBrew for one, maybe Revvy) say that they just dump it all in. It will settle out on the bottom, if you patiently primary for long enough! :)
 
If you have a spigot on your kettle, it's easy to do a whirlpool so most of the crap settles in the middle of the kettle. That way you leave the bulk of it behind. You get some in the fermenter, but not all of it.
 
I'm not too sure about the time in the primary. I think the instructions say, 5 to 7 days. It is all about the specific gravity the recipe calls for,,right??
 
I usually dump it all in, but I do keep in primary for at least a month. and for ^^ once your hydrometer reads the same for three consecutive days then it is ok to bottle. Like I said before though; I usually leave in fermentor for a month so there is usually no question whether fermentation is complete or not.
 
I'm not too sure about the time in the primary. I think the instructions say, 5 to 7 days. It is all about the specific gravity the recipe calls for,,right??

I thought the same thing but after reading many threads here I think 2 weeks is a minimum. You don't want any fermentation going on in your bottles! They'll turn into bombs.
 
I'm not too sure about the time in the primary. I think the instructions say, 5 to 7 days. It is all about the specific gravity the recipe calls for,,right??

Well, it will probably be about finished fermenting in a week- but the beer won't be "done" by a long shot.

Even after the active fermentation is over, the yeast are working. One of the things they do is digest their own waste products, when they run out of sugars to eat. After that, they begin to clump together and fall out of suspension, falling to the bottom. That means the beer will become clearer and less yeasty tasting. If you're going right to a keg, I'd suggest waiting about three weeks before kegging. For people using a secondary, the beer can be moved there to clear and condition some.

Even though it's possible to carbonate beer that's only a week old, it generally is better to give it a bit more time. For most beers, I like to keg them when they are about 4 weeks old, then allow them to condition at room temperature for a week or two, then put them in the kegerator to get them cold and ready to drink.

One of the reasons some kit instructions say to ferment for a week and then bottle is to sell the kit. I mean, if the package said "Ready in just 6 weeks!", not too many new brewers would jump at it. But that's more realistic, and gives better beer.
 
Okay,
Sorry about asking questions that I should know by reading the books, however.

My beer has been in the primary for 7 days now. It has slowed to about one burp every 60 seconds. I want to rack it into my secondary for I don't know how long and then keg it. Is this what I should do?

Thanks,
Ron
 
You could do that, but I never bother with a second stage except for some special purpose. And on your original question, I never worry about what goes into my primary - everything eventually settles to the bottom and compacts itself. I guess if you like to use a second stage after one week in the primary, maybe it would matter more that you keep stuff out of the primary, but by three weeks, everything is settled and the beer is nice and clear. Careful siphoning into the bottling bucket does the rest.
 
Back
Top