ElDuderino
Well-Known Member
Thanks for your level headed response, damdaman. I didn't start this thread to debate whether this beer deserves it's own category or whether it's just a hoppy stout/porter or whether it's just a dark ipa or whether it even deserves to exist. I don't disagree that there can be, should be or is often a pronounced roast character in the beers people have tried in this style. I had a particular beer made by a local brewery here that I really liked and would like to make. It did not have as much roast and malt character as the Widmere black ipa or the dogzilla I've had, not that I have anything against those beers. I appreciate all the responses that have guided me closer to my goal. Many of the others, while often passionate, weren't really helpful; then again, I can't say they weren't entertaining to read.