• Please visit and share your knowledge at our sister communities:
    Cheesemaking Forum Cast Iron Forum Canning Forum Ceramic Grills
    Espresso Forum Hot Pepper Forums Pizza Oven Forums
  • If you have not, please join our official Homebrewing Facebook Group!

    Homebrewing Facebook Group

Brewing Irish Stout

Brewer's Friend 728
Homebrew Talk

Help Support Homebrew Talk:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
R

RishoBrew

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 5, 2015
Messages
51
Reaction score
6
Location
Black Forest
Hi, how important is a secondary fermentation for Irish Stout type beer? In theory I understand what secondary fermentation does but I need the carboy for my next brew and since the recipe indicated the secondary as optional has anyone did both and can elaborate on results? Thanks.
 
Secondary is well regarded as an obsolete practice unless you are aging more than 6 months... and even then, it's controversial.
 
I've done both. Went direct to keg on my last batch and I don't think it made much, if any, difference.
 
I stopped using a secondary as of recent from all the advise on here, my last batch was straight primary and I dont notice much of a difference. I now only use secondary for adding something to the batch or if I end up needing one of my fermentors for a new batch.
 
Craft A Brew - LalBrew BRY-97™American West Coast Ale Yeast - American Beer Dry Yeast - For Craft Lagers - Ingredients for Home Brewing - Beer Making Supplies - (1 Pack)
$7.49 ($19.30 / Ounce)
Craft A Brew - LalBrew BRY-97™American West Coast Ale Yeast - American Beer Dry Yeast - For Craft Lagers - Ingredients for Home Brewing - Beer Making Supplies - (1 Pack) Craft a Brew
Circrane Hydrometer & Glass Test Jar Set, Triple Scale Alcohol Hydrometer with Glass Cylinder for Brew Beer, Wine, Mead and Kombucha, ABV, Brix and Gravity Test Kit, Home Brewing Supplies
$12.99
Circrane Hydrometer & Glass Test Jar Set, Triple Scale Alcohol Hydrometer with Glass Cylinder for Brew Beer, Wine, Mead and Kombucha, ABV, Brix and Gravity Test Kit, Home Brewing Supplies Circrane LTD
Hydrometer - Triple Scale Hydrometer for Home Brewing - Beer and Wine
$7.19
Hydrometer - Triple Scale Hydrometer for Home Brewing - Beer and Wine Amazon.com
Hornindal Kveik Yeast for Homebrewing - Mead, Cider, Wine, Beer - 10g Packet - Saccharomyces Cerevisiae - Sold by Shadowhive.com
$10.99 ($31.16 / Ounce)
Hornindal Kveik Yeast for Homebrewing - Mead, Cider, Wine, Beer - 10g Packet - Saccharomyces Cerevisiae - Sold by Shadowhive.com Shadowhive
12 Pack Pgzsy Mini Small Digital Electronic Temperature Humidity Meters Gauge Indoor Thermometer Hygrometer LCD Display Fahrenheit (℉) for Humidors, Greenhouse, Garden
$15.99
12 Pack Pgzsy Mini Small Digital Electronic Temperature Humidity Meters Gauge Indoor Thermometer Hygrometer LCD Display Fahrenheit (℉) for Humidors, Greenhouse, Garden Pgzsy
Inkbird ITC-308 Digital Temperature Controller 2-Stage Outlet Thermostat Heating and Cooling Mode Carboy Homebrew Fermenter Greenhouse Terrarium 110V 10A
$35.00 ($2.30 / oz)
Inkbird ITC-308 Digital Temperature Controller 2-Stage Outlet Thermostat Heating and Cooling Mode Carboy Homebrew Fermenter Greenhouse Terrarium 110V 10A Inkbird
Brewer's Best Home Brew Beer Ingredient Kit - 5 Gallon (Mexican Cerveza)
$39.22
Brewer's Best Home Brew Beer Ingredient Kit - 5 Gallon (Mexican Cerveza) Amazon.com
Craft A Brew - Mead Making Kit – Reusable Make Your Own Mead Kit – Yields 1 Gallon of Mead
-10%
$44.99 $49.95
Craft A Brew - Mead Making Kit – Reusable Make Your Own Mead Kit – Yields 1 Gallon of Mead Craft a Brew
Fermus Set of 2 Cold Brew Coffee Filter for 64oz / 2Quart Wide Mouth Mason Jar Infuser 304 Stainless Steel Strainer with Seal Ring Design for Grounds Tea Fruit Coffee Filter
$16.99 ($8.50 / Count)
Fermus Set of 2 Cold Brew Coffee Filter for 64oz / 2Quart Wide Mouth Mason Jar Infuser 304 Stainless Steel Strainer with Seal Ring Design for Grounds Tea Fruit Coffee Filter Fermus
Craft a Brew - Beer Recipe Kit - Light Lager - Home Brewing Ingredient Refill - Beer Making Supplies - Includes Hops, Yeast, Malts, Extracts - 5 Gallons
$56.99 ($0.09 / Fl Oz)
Craft a Brew - Beer Recipe Kit - Light Lager - Home Brewing Ingredient Refill - Beer Making Supplies - Includes Hops, Yeast, Malts, Extracts - 5 Gallons Craft a Brew
FERRODAY Wort Brewing Pump, Stainless Head Magnetic Drive Brew Food Safe Water High Temp Homebrew Beer Pump with 1/2" NPT Thread
$58.39
FERRODAY Wort Brewing Pump, Stainless Head Magnetic Drive Brew Food Safe Water High Temp Homebrew Beer Pump with 1/2" NPT Thread Brewhouse168
Craft A Brew - Safale WB-06 Dry Yeast - German Wheat Beer Dry Yeast - for Wheat Beers - Ingredients for Home Brewing - Beer Making Supplies - 1 Pack
$7.95
Craft A Brew - Safale WB-06 Dry Yeast - German Wheat Beer Dry Yeast - for Wheat Beers - Ingredients for Home Brewing - Beer Making Supplies - 1 Pack Craft a Brew
Fermtech - Auto Siphon Mini with 6 Ft of Food Safe Tubing & Clamp - Easy Home Brewing, Winemaking Kit, Complete System for Beer, Wine, Liquid Transfer & Fermentation Tools - Perfect for Small Batches
$15.99
Fermtech - Auto Siphon Mini with 6 Ft of Food Safe Tubing & Clamp - Easy Home Brewing, Winemaking Kit, Complete System for Beer, Wine, Liquid Transfer & Fermentation Tools - Perfect for Small Batches UBREW USA
Fermtech Pro Filler with 6.5 Feet of Food Safe NSF-51 Certified Tubing - Auto Bottle Filler Wand for Bottling, Racking, Filling, & Brewing Equipment for Beer, Wine, Water & Craft Kits - Made in Canada
$12.99
Fermtech Pro Filler with 6.5 Feet of Food Safe NSF-51 Certified Tubing - Auto Bottle Filler Wand for Bottling, Racking, Filling, & Brewing Equipment for Beer, Wine, Water & Craft Kits - Made in Canada UBREW USA
Mead Making Kit – Complete Honey Wine Brewing Kit with Reusable Equipment, Glass Fermenter, Airlock & Yeast – DIY Homebrew Kit for Beginners & Experts- This Mead Kit Makes 1 Gallon of Mead. Must Bee Company
$49.95
Mead Making Kit – Complete Honey Wine Brewing Kit with Reusable Equipment, Glass Fermenter, Airlock & Yeast – DIY Homebrew Kit for Beginners & Experts- This Mead Kit Makes 1 Gallon of Mead. Must Bee Company Must Bee Company, LLC
aichose Brix Refractometer with ATC, Dual Scale - Specific Gravity & Brix, Hydrometer in Wine Making and Beer Brewing, Homebrew Kit
-35%
$18.99 $29.20
aichose Brix Refractometer with ATC, Dual Scale - Specific Gravity & Brix, Hydrometer in Wine Making and Beer Brewing, Homebrew Kit Top Town
6 Pack Mini Hygrometer Indoor Humidity Meter, Small Digital Thermometer Humidity Gauge Meter, Indoor Thermometer Hygrometer Monitor Fahrenheit (℉) for Humidor, Thermostat Reptile Tank, Mason Jars
-29%
$6.37 $8.99
6 Pack Mini Hygrometer Indoor Humidity Meter, Small Digital Thermometer Humidity Gauge Meter, Indoor Thermometer Hygrometer Monitor Fahrenheit (℉) for Humidor, Thermostat Reptile Tank, Mason Jars JJMTDS
Craft A Brew - Polycarbonate Hydrometer - Triple Scale - Measures Potential Alcohol Content & Density of Sugar - Durable & Built to Last - Specific Gravity, Potential ABV, & Brix
$10.99
Craft A Brew - Polycarbonate Hydrometer - Triple Scale - Measures Potential Alcohol Content & Density of Sugar - Durable & Built to Last - Specific Gravity, Potential ABV, & Brix Craft a Brew
2 Pack 1 Gallon Large Fermentation Jars with 3 Airlocks and 2 SCREW Lids(100% Airtight Heavy Duty Lid w Silicone) - Wide Mouth Glass Jars w Scale Mark - Pickle Jars for Sauerkraut, Sourdough Starter
-19%
$33.99 ($17.00 / Count) $41.99 ($21.00 / Count)
2 Pack 1 Gallon Large Fermentation Jars with 3 Airlocks and 2 SCREW Lids(100% Airtight Heavy Duty Lid w Silicone) - Wide Mouth Glass Jars w Scale Mark - Pickle Jars for Sauerkraut, Sourdough Starter Qianfenie Direct
Craft A Brew - Mead Yeast Nutrient Bundle - Lalvin D47 Yeast - For Fermentation - Home Brewing Ingredients - Mead Making Supplies - Yields 10 Gallons
$34.99
Craft A Brew - Mead Yeast Nutrient Bundle - Lalvin D47 Yeast - For Fermentation - Home Brewing Ingredients - Mead Making Supplies - Yields 10 Gallons Craft a Brew
FastRack Triple-Scale Hydrometer - ABV Hydrometer - Specific Gravity Hydrometer to accurately Test ABV and the Specific Gravity of Your Wine, Beer, Mead or Kombucha
-8%
$7.19 $7.79
FastRack Triple-Scale Hydrometer - ABV Hydrometer - Specific Gravity Hydrometer to accurately Test ABV and the Specific Gravity of Your Wine, Beer, Mead or Kombucha Amazon.com
1pc Hose Barb/MFL 1.5" Tri Clamp to Ball Lock Post Liquid Gas Homebrew Kegging Fermentation Parts Brewer Hardware SUS304(Liquid Hose Barb)
$53.24
1pc Hose Barb/MFL 1.5" Tri Clamp to Ball Lock Post Liquid Gas Homebrew Kegging Fermentation Parts Brewer Hardware SUS304(Liquid Hose Barb) Guangshui Weilu You Trading Co., Ltd
FastRack 1 Gallon Mason Jar Wide Mouth & Twin Bubble Airlock (Pack of 2) | for Fermentation, Pickling, Brewing & Dry Storage – BPA-Free One Gallon Glass Jar with Lid
$25.29 ($12.64 / Count)
FastRack 1 Gallon Mason Jar Wide Mouth & Twin Bubble Airlock (Pack of 2) | for Fermentation, Pickling, Brewing & Dry Storage – BPA-Free One Gallon Glass Jar with Lid Amazon.com
Brewer's Elite Hydrometer - for Home Brew Beer, Wine, Mead and Kombucha - Deluxe Triple Scale Set, Hardcase and Cloth - Specific Gravity ABV Tester
$12.99
Brewer's Elite Hydrometer - for Home Brew Beer, Wine, Mead and Kombucha - Deluxe Triple Scale Set, Hardcase and Cloth - Specific Gravity ABV Tester Unicorp Ltd
3 Pcs Cold Brew Coffee Filter Stainless Steel Filter Coffee Tea Infuser Coffee Strainer Canning Jar Mesh Coffee Filter for Wide Mouth Mason Canning Jar, Iced Tea Maker
$17.99 ($6.00 / Count)
3 Pcs Cold Brew Coffee Filter Stainless Steel Filter Coffee Tea Infuser Coffee Strainer Canning Jar Mesh Coffee Filter for Wide Mouth Mason Canning Jar, Iced Tea Maker Tigermarket
E-Found 60W Liquid Transfer Pump, Water, Soft Drink, Wine Transfer Pump 110V Speed Adjustable Food Grade Self-Priming Pump for Pumping Beverages Filter with Tube, with Filter Screen 4-5L/Min
$42.99
E-Found 60W Liquid Transfer Pump, Water, Soft Drink, Wine Transfer Pump 110V Speed Adjustable Food Grade Self-Priming Pump for Pumping Beverages Filter with Tube, with Filter Screen 4-5L/Min E-Found
Craft A Brew - One Step No Rinse Cleanser - For Cleaning At Home Brewing Equipment - Non-Foaming Cleanser - Safe & Easy to Use - Home Brewing Supplies - 8 oz
$9.99 ($1.25 / Ounce)
Craft A Brew - One Step No Rinse Cleanser - For Cleaning At Home Brewing Equipment - Non-Foaming Cleanser - Safe & Easy to Use - Home Brewing Supplies - 8 oz Craft a Brew
Tilt Wireless Orange Hydrometer and Thermometer: Patented Brewing Technology for Precision Monitoring & Control for Fermentation of Beer, Wine, Cider, Mead & More
$135.00
Tilt Wireless Orange Hydrometer and Thermometer: Patented Brewing Technology for Precision Monitoring & Control for Fermentation of Beer, Wine, Cider, Mead & More Tilt Hydrometer
Craft A Brew - LalBrew Voss™ - Kveik Ale Yeast - For Craft Lagers - Ingredients for Home Brewing - Beer Making Supplies - (1 Pack)
$7.79 ($7.79 / Count)
Craft A Brew - LalBrew Voss™ - Kveik Ale Yeast - For Craft Lagers - Ingredients for Home Brewing - Beer Making Supplies - (1 Pack) Craft a Brew
Brewer's Elite Hydrometer & Plastic Test Jar - for Home Brew Beer, Wine, Mead and Kombucha - Deluxe Triple Scale Set, Hardcase and Cloth - Specific Gravity ABV Tester
$21.99
Brewer's Elite Hydrometer & Plastic Test Jar - for Home Brew Beer, Wine, Mead and Kombucha - Deluxe Triple Scale Set, Hardcase and Cloth - Specific Gravity ABV Tester Unicorp Ltd
ASDJKL Home Brewing Keg Ball Lock Faucet 30cm Reinforced Silicone Hose Secondary Fermentation Homebrew Kegging Brewing Accessories
$55.87
ASDJKL Home Brewing Keg Ball Lock Faucet 30cm Reinforced Silicone Hose Secondary Fermentation Homebrew Kegging Brewing Accessories yayangyang
HUIZHUGS Brewing Equipment Keg Ball Lock Faucet 30cm Reinforced Silicone Hose Secondary Fermentation Homebrew Kegging Brewing Equipment
$58.16
HUIZHUGS Brewing Equipment Keg Ball Lock Faucet 30cm Reinforced Silicone Hose Secondary Fermentation Homebrew Kegging Brewing Equipment xiangshuizhenzhanglingfengshop
The Brew Your Own Big Book of Clone Recipes: Featuring 300 Homebrew Recipes from Your Favorite Breweries
-30%
$20.94 $29.99
The Brew Your Own Big Book of Clone Recipes: Featuring 300 Homebrew Recipes from Your Favorite Breweries Amazon.com
Craft A Brew - Safale S-04 Dry Yeast - Fermentis - English Ale Dry Yeast - For English and American Ales and Hard Apple Ciders - Ingredients for Home Brewing - Beer Making Supplies - [1 Pack]
-7%
$6.95 ($17.38 / Ounce) $7.47 ($18.68 / Ounce)
Craft A Brew - Safale S-04 Dry Yeast - Fermentis - English Ale Dry Yeast - For English and American Ales and Hard Apple Ciders - Ingredients for Home Brewing - Beer Making Supplies - [1 Pack] Hobby Homebrew
JIAWANSHUN 110V Electric Wine Transfer Pump, 5L/Min Food Grade Self-Priming Pump w/Stepless Speed Control, Stainless Steel Filters & 13.12ft Hose - for Home Brewing, Beverages, Low Noise
$42.98
JIAWANSHUN 110V Electric Wine Transfer Pump, 5L/Min Food Grade Self-Priming Pump w/Stepless Speed Control, Stainless Steel Filters & 13.12ft Hose - for Home Brewing, Beverages, Low Noise JIAWANSHUNUS
Five Star - 6022b_ - Star San - 32 Ounce - High Foaming Sanitizer
$30.95
Five Star - 6022b_ - Star San - 32 Ounce - High Foaming Sanitizer Home Brew Ohio
Monkkino Brew Bags, 2pcs Brew In A Bag, Reusable Wine Straining Bag for Homebrewing, Fine Mesh Bag for Boiling, Durable Mesh Strainer Bag, 22×26 & 16x18
-20%
$6.39 $7.99
Monkkino Brew Bags, 2pcs Brew In A Bag, Reusable Wine Straining Bag for Homebrewing, Fine Mesh Bag for Boiling, Durable Mesh Strainer Bag, 22×26 & 16x18 Monkkino
1pc Hose Barb/MFL 1.5" Tri Clamp to Ball Lock Post Liquid Gas Homebrew Kegging Fermentation Parts Brewer Hardware SUS304(Liquid Hose Barb)
$53.24
1pc Hose Barb/MFL 1.5" Tri Clamp to Ball Lock Post Liquid Gas Homebrew Kegging Fermentation Parts Brewer Hardware SUS304(Liquid Hose Barb) yunchengshiyanhuqucuichendianzishangwuyouxiangongsi
1pc Commercial Keg Manifold 2" Tri Clamp,Ball Lock Tapping Head,Pressure Gauge/Adjustable PRV for Kegging,Fermentation Control
$176.97
1pc Commercial Keg Manifold 2" Tri Clamp,Ball Lock Tapping Head,Pressure Gauge/Adjustable PRV for Kegging,Fermentation Control hanhanbaihuoxiaoshoudian
3"Tri Clamp Fermenters ball lock post Convert Lid with Gas Post Beer Post PRV,Fermentasaurus Pressure,Homebrew Kegging fermentation Equipment
$42.99
3"Tri Clamp Fermenters ball lock post Convert Lid with Gas Post Beer Post PRV,Fermentasaurus Pressure,Homebrew Kegging fermentation Equipment homebrew supply
Brewing accessories 1.5" Tri Clamp to Ball Lock Post Liquid Gas Homebrew Kegging Fermentation Parts Brewer Hardware SUS304 Brewing accessories(Liquid Hose Barb)
$79.19
Brewing accessories 1.5" Tri Clamp to Ball Lock Post Liquid Gas Homebrew Kegging Fermentation Parts Brewer Hardware SUS304 Brewing accessories(Liquid Hose Barb) chuhanhandianzishangwu
Inkbird ITC-308 Digital Temperature Controller 2-Stage Outlet Thermostat Heating and Cooling Mode Carboy Homebrew Fermenter Greenhouse Terrarium 110V 10A
$35.00 ($2.30 / oz)
Inkbird ITC-308 Digital Temperature Controller 2-Stage Outlet Thermostat Heating and Cooling Mode Carboy Homebrew Fermenter Greenhouse Terrarium 110V 10A Inkbird
EasyDens Digital Hydrometer by Anton Paar – Bluetooth-Enabled for Precise Alcohol, Sugar, and Extract Measurement | Fast ABV Tester for Homebrewing, Distilling, Beer, Wine, Kombucha, and Spirits
$449.00
EasyDens Digital Hydrometer by Anton Paar – Bluetooth-Enabled for Precise Alcohol, Sugar, and Extract Measurement | Fast ABV Tester for Homebrewing, Distilling, Beer, Wine, Kombucha, and Spirits Anton Paar ConsumerTec
Inkbird ITC-308 Digital Temperature Controller Outlet Thermostat 2-Stage 1100W with Sensor Reptile Beer Brewing Kegs Fridge Cured Meat Breeding Growing
$35.00 ($35.00 / Count)
Inkbird ITC-308 Digital Temperature Controller Outlet Thermostat 2-Stage 1100W with Sensor Reptile Beer Brewing Kegs Fridge Cured Meat Breeding Growing Inkbird
VINUM Carboy Cleaner - 27" Long Bottle Brush for Carboys, Jugs, Water Bottles & Demijohns - Modular & Universal Scrub Brush Cleaning Supplies for Brewing & Wine Making Equipment
$32.99
VINUM Carboy Cleaner - 27" Long Bottle Brush for Carboys, Jugs, Water Bottles & Demijohns - Modular & Universal Scrub Brush Cleaning Supplies for Brewing & Wine Making Equipment Lykit
VEVOR Electric Brewing System, 9.2 Gal/35 L Brewing Pot, All-in-One Home Beer Brewer w/Pump, Mash Boil Device w/Panel, Auto/Manual Mode 100-1800W Power 25-100℃ Temp 1-180 min Timer Recipe Memory
-30%
$259.99 $368.99
VEVOR Electric Brewing System, 9.2 Gal/35 L Brewing Pot, All-in-One Home Beer Brewer w/Pump, Mash Boil Device w/Panel, Auto/Manual Mode 100-1800W Power 25-100℃ Temp 1-180 min Timer Recipe Memory Simplego
AMZLMPKNTW Ball Lock Sample Faucet 30cm Reinforced Silicone Hose Secondary Fermentation Homebrew Kegging joyful
$22.00 ($623.23 / Ounce)
AMZLMPKNTW Ball Lock Sample Faucet 30cm Reinforced Silicone Hose Secondary Fermentation Homebrew Kegging joyful 无为中南商贸有限公司
Hydrometer Test Kit, Triple Scale Alcohol Tester Hydrometer for Wine, Beer, Kombucha & Mead, Wine Making Kit, (ABV Tester, Brix, Specific Gravity Hydrometer) + Hydrometer Test Jar for Home Brewing Kit
$14.97 ($2.99 / Count)
Hydrometer Test Kit, Triple Scale Alcohol Tester Hydrometer for Wine, Beer, Kombucha & Mead, Wine Making Kit, (ABV Tester, Brix, Specific Gravity Hydrometer) + Hydrometer Test Jar for Home Brewing Kit CIMALAB Direct
2 Inch Tri Clamp Keg Manifold With Ball Lock Posts, Pressure Gauge, PRV (0-30 PSI) – Homebrew, Fermentation, Kegging System
$172.35
2 Inch Tri Clamp Keg Manifold With Ball Lock Posts, Pressure Gauge, PRV (0-30 PSI) – Homebrew, Fermentation, Kegging System TYDLCLTY

Similar threads

leedspointbrew
Simple dark mild recipe
Replies
16
Views
2K
Miraculix
Miraculix
B
Moving from Fermenter to Bottling Bucket
Replies
12
Views
1K
Snuffy
Snuffy
mhburgat@#gmail.com
Purple Ube Stout
Replies
5
Views
822
skibb
skibb
S
Planning my first non-kit brew - so many questions
Replies
16
Views
1K
OakIslandBrewery
OakIslandBrewery
agentbud
Apple Pie Oatmeal Stout
Replies
2
Views
423
day_trippr
day_trippr
InkBird 300

Latest posts

Back
Top