you don't normally take the OG from the first runnings, but from a heavily mixed solution of the first runnings and sparge water... i.e. at the full 5-6 gallons pre boil
then do another post boil before pitching. Am I misunderstanding something or does that make sense? i.e. the first runnings are going to be really high gravity, but adding the second round will significantly reduce the gravity... something like for a 1.050 beer, the first runnings may be like 1.070 and second 1.030 and they merge to 1.050... (making those numbers off, so don't think they're anywhere close to real, just an example)