To anyone stumbling upon this thread, and actually reading it this far
, Just updating on my progress with this recipe.
After my first experiment, which I detailed in this thread, I've gotten some slightly better equipment (anything is a step up from milk jugs). My buddy gave me some 1gal glass jugs he found in the basement of a house he used to live in, and I got some proper air locks and stoppers from the home brew store.
Regarding my first experiment, btw, the last bottle of it remains on the shelf. I have to say that it really hasn't aged at all - the 2nd to last bottle (now gone) was almost identical to the first sip I took of the stuff after 2 months. So I don't know if it's the type of yeast or what but with regards to the other people saying it will age out to different tastes, I haven't had that experience. After 6 months on the shelf it is very nearly identical to when I bottled it.
I get the point of this recipe. It's the way they might have done it back when cars and street lights were horses and lanterns. Back when dudes and chicks were lords and ladies. And that's cool. I also like that it is an idiot-proof starting point for someone who's never brewed before. But for me after that first batch it's hard not to want to work towards some improvement in the recipe. So this current batch isn't a true JAOM. I kind of think that's the point, though... this recipe is such a great place to start, it begs you to put your own spin on it. Just don't call it JAOM when you're done!
My recipe for this batch was the same as the JAOM posted here,
except:
- I used 3lb honey per gallon.
- I juiced the orange and discarded all large solids (left the pulp). Sorry, but I've just had enough of the pithy rind taste to last me a while.
- I added the juice of half a pomagranate (aiming for something festive for Christmastime).
- I made 2 separate gallons - one with bread yeast per JAOM, one with wine yeast. (Just to experiment and see if I can tell a difference in the final product.)
- I used a yeast nutrient.
Equipment-wise, in addition to the "new" (60 year old) glass jugs with real stoppers and air locks, I also picked up some of that no-rinse sanitizer and I have to say that is really convenient stuff. Well worth the cost.
So I melted the honey in water, put in all of the ingredients, made sure the temp of the solution was reasonable for the yeast, pitched the 2 yeasts, and shook the heck out of both jugs.
12 hours later it was clear that I'd over-filled the jugs... lesson learned the hard way
DEFINITELY leave some head space in the jug for the first few days. Both of my air locks got all fouled and burped half-fermented orange pulp all over the wall of my wife's home office, but she took it all in stride (bless her) and eventually I got them swapped out and everything is tidy and happy now.
The born-on date is October 10, so it's been a week and a half and both gallons are still bubbling away happy as can be. They are in a dark closet where the temp is 60F - 65F. I will post here when they are done and tasted if anyone is curious how this recipe turned out.
My next experiment (just put up on Sunday) is apple cider - I'll post about that in the cider forum.