Bodega is usually super packed and full of hipsters... You could try Barleys Smokehouse in Grandview (?), Neil House Brewery but have to check hours of operations... Depending where you are in NE Ohio (I grew up right off the lake), you might have heard or been to Winking Lizard, good beer selection. Beer stores? The Andersons off of Sawmil Rd and Kenny Rd market off of Bethel Rd are 2 of the best.
Elevator Brewing Co was pretty good as is Columbus Brewing Co both could be options for you.
If you are willing to make a 30 minute trip, Buckeye Lake Brewery is quite new to the scene, but had some tasty options.