I, also, was optimistic when I heard the league's latest offer.
To quibble over a few percentage points of their 7-figure salaries is ridiculous. In fact, there should actually be a not-insignificant portion of players who actually stand to lose more in the long run by only making strike pay for the year (EVEN IF they manage to keep it at 57%, which they won't), rather than accepting a few percentage points less. Granted, the more highly-paid players would at first glance be the players in this group, so it might not initially seem to really matter all that much. But salary is only one half of the equation, the other half being the number of years left in a player's career. And the lower-salaried grinders tend to have much shorter careers than the highly-paid superstars, so in actuality I'd imagine that the *least* paid players are actually the *most* affected by this.
Of course, while there are undoubtedly SOME number of players who will end up overall making less by missing the year, the size and composition of this group as described is largely conjecture. But it would be interesting to see an actual, in-depth, statistical analysis, and it could maybe possibly even provide somewhat of a reality check for a chunk of the players. And a reality check is exactly what these ******** need - they're screwing over a lot of people (and not even really the owners!) by bitching about a few percentage points when many of them will regardless make more in a year than most people make in a lifetime. They really have to get their heads out of their asses.
For a bit of perspective, Stamkos went to my high school, a freshman while I was in my senior year. The kid worked hard to get where he is. But so did dozens (if not hundreds) of the other kids that were in the same building that year, and it's unlikely that even a single one of them is making even a tenth of what he is. That's not to knock on Stamkos specifically, as he's a pretty down to earth guy (a total geek, really). I'm just pointing out how these players should really be counting their blessings rather than throwing this whole collective entitlement-tantrum.