Ok revival of a dead thread, bit hopefully we can get this thread moving.
Tried this for the first time this year and would say it's one of the better "cream" stouts I've ever had.
Bell's doesn't give much info on their site, I think the key to the mouth feel, creaminess since there's no lactose is the FG.
They stayed this on their site
Alcohol By Volume: 6.10%
Original Gravity: 1.08
Which means the FG is close to 1.033
So, first question is how to get the attenuation that low, and what yeast strain, could be Windsor since it's known for very low attenuation.
Then it's what 10 malts are they using? I would guess Pale Ale for the base, has worked good for me to get a sweeter finish, then a heavy amount of Munich, maybe 50/50 with the Pale and Munich. A good amount of darker caramel, maybe around 120.
That's 3 malts. From their I would say 1 or 2 other caramel malts, some chocolate and pale chocolate, and/or some chocolate wheat, some roasted barley, and maybe some flaked oats.
I'm planning to try to email them and see if they'll give any insight into the 10 malts seeing of my guess is are remotely close. I really think getting the OG and FG to work out will be tough. Has to be a combo of mash temp, the grains being used, and yeast strain. Once you can get the FG right I would only carbonate to around 1.8 vols CO2.
From what I've read about Bell's they're "house" strain is WY1272, but with my experience with that strain I don't see how you'd get it to finish so high without killing the yeast.
They list Nugget as the only hop with 10 IBU. With my recent experience of using Nugget as a flavor/aroma hop they're definitely adding it early in small amounts. Nugget is known for being a good bittering hop, but from personal experience now it's a very floral flavor and aroma hop, not in a good/tasty way. So, in all honesty I think almost any good clean bittering hop could.be used.