You need to customize the equipment set-up and brewing steps to match your system and methods to get the best results from BeerSmith. It is a commonly underestimated part of getting the program to work correctly for the way you brew.
^ This. Go over to the beersmith site and search for equipment profile. There are several articles and examples on how to set up a custom profile. Once you have that set up, the rest should fall into place.
Ok I have a 12qt pot, maybe I'm just confused on the size of the grain bill it's saying like 8lbs is that right? I thought 1 gallon batches require 2-4 lbs... I was lookin at a blue moon clone to help get my woman interested in brewing...
For the equipment profile, play with boil off rates and fermenter loss. Once you think you have it, you can use the Calculate Boil volume automatically.