Advice: 15 Gallon Blichmann vs Keggle

[mcp369]

I'm just getting started in home brewing and want to upgrade my brew kettle. I'm still doing 5 gallon extract brewing currently while learning the ropes but hope to move to brew in a bag or full AG in the future.

Found a used 15 gallon Blichmann g1 with false bottom for 200 and a used Keggle with ball lock, thermometer, and volume sight for 150.

Is the Blichmann worth the 50 extra or are there better alternatives?

 

[sillbeer]

I would say the Blichmann is worth it since it comes with a false bottom. It'll come in handy when/if you start doing BIAB. I assume you are using a burner?

If you are interested in 10 gallon brews I would suggest a 20 gallon kettle for BIAB.

 

[mcp369]

Yes I am using a burner. Made the mistake of doing my first batch on an electric stove top which took forever to heat.

 

[k1ngl1ves]

That's a good price for a g1 with a false bottom. I'd choose that. If it's on cl, you can probably get it a bit cheaper too. Maybe $175 or $180...

 

[AkTom]

I've never even seen a Blichman. Tempting yes.
I have to say, I love my keggle and ball lock. Either way, brew on.

 

[mcp369]

Thanks for all the replies. I think I will go with the Blichmann. Talked to the guy and he is set on 200 for it but after seeing the replies on here I feel like I am getting a good deal especially for my little start up home brewing.

 

[sillbeer]

They hold their value well. If you take care of it you should be able to recover your money if and when you decide to go with a larger kettle.

 

[wilserbrewer]

Jmo, kettle over keggle all day long. Kettles are purpose designed for boiling / mashing. Kegs are purpose designed for serving / kegging.