I have the 2nd one and I use it for a portable camping shower. There are two downsides to using this pump for brewing:
1. It's not a mag drive, so there is a seal on the impeller shaft and it would be near impossible to insure proper sanitation.
2. It requires a 12 volt DC power supply and a hefty one at that. You could run it with a car battery, which is what I use, but I think there are much better alternatives.
3. It's a self priming pump and it does not like to be throttled back with a flow control valve. It can be done, but the power draw goes up big time and if continued for very long it will likely overheat the pump. These pumps are not really designed for continuous use.
4. These pumps are noisy.