When to dry hop

Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum

Help Support Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

pfish83

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 12, 2011
Messages
62
Reaction score
1
Location
Baltimore
This is my first attempt at brewing and I have decided I want to dry hop. I am making the brewer's best IPA. I transferred my beer to the secondary carboy on Friday (14th). Should I have dry hopped immediately after racking or is it not too late to do it tomorrow (20th)?

Second question...are Cascade hop Pellets good for dry hopping or do you guys suggest a different style?

Final question...I have some hop bags that I didn't use in the boil...would you suggest dropping them into the carboy or just dropping the pellets directly in?

Thanks.
 
I think you will get different answers from everyone. Some people will say they always dry hop for 7 days and other will say up to 14 days. Same thing on the bags. Some swear by them and others just toss the hops in the carboy. I just did my first dry hopped IPA (pellets) a couple weeks ago and I went with the bag weighted with marbles and am going to leave it for two weeks. The next one I will probably do something different just so I can see which methods I prefer and learn how different amounts of time impart more/less/different aromas.

HTH,
Jason

Edit: Cascades are fine for dry hopping. If you attach your recipe I'm sure others can help critique.
 
Should I have dry hopped immediately after racking or is it not too late to do it tomorrow (20th)?

When you dry-hop, you have two competing pressures: if you dry-hop during active fermentation, the CO2 being produced tends to drive off the hop aroma. If, on the other hand, you dry-hop after active fermentation has ended, the oxygen that's trapped in the hops will be transmitted to the beer, and result in staling.

Mike "Tasty" McDole's strategy is to dry hop at the very tail end of active fermentation. If you feel like too much of the hop aroma is driven off, his solution is to just add more hops.

My own strategy is to add the hops after active fermentation has ended. My beer gets drunk within a few weeks of being bottled or kegged, so staling and flavor stability isn't a big concern for me.

I'm not aware of anyone who advocates adding the hops on the same day, or even the day after brewing, so I think you might be jumping the gun a little. Regardless, you're definitely not too late to add your dry hops today, or later this week.

are Cascade hop Pellets good for dry hopping or do you guys suggest a different style?

Cascade hops are fine to dry hop with, if you enjoy cascade's aroma. This is an important distinction, because dry hopping doesn't add much bitterness or flavor to the beer. I personally think that cascade is a really clean smelling hop, and using it to dry hop makes a drinkable beer. I often use Amarillo instead when I want something a little more interesting.

In short, cascade will work, but whether it's "good for dry hopping" is entirely a matter of preference.

I have some hop bags that I didn't use in the boil...would you suggest dropping them into the carboy or just dropping the pellets directly in?

Some people use bag to contain their dry hops, others don't. Tasty, for instance, does. Jamil, on the other hand, doesn't.

My suggestion is that a hops bag is appropriate whenever you add so many hops that some of the hops don't touch the wort. (That happens to me a lot when I add leaf hops instead of pellets.) When that happens, the best idea is to sanitize the bag and a couple of heavy stainless steel washers or glass marbles, weight the bag with the washers/marbles so it sinks, toss in the hops, and then add the whole thing to the fermenter.*

If, on the other hand, you're only using an ounce or two of pellet hops, adding them to the wort without a bag is just fine. They'll sink rapidly on their own, so you don't have to worry about weighting them. If you're concerned about your beer's clarity (e.g. you don't want to have floating bits of hops in your glass) then you can either allow it to condition for longer, filter it, cold crash it, add finings, add gelatin, etc. Really, I haven't found clarity to be closely tied to whether or not you use a hops bag to contain dry hops.

*Lots of people dry hop in their primary fermenter. Other people prefer to dry hop in their secondary fermenter. Unless you plan to let the beer sit for a LONG time on the yeast, it's largely a matter of personal technique, so either will be fine.
 
I'm not aware of anyone who advocates adding the hops on the same day, or even the day after brewing, so I think you might be jumping the gun a little. Regardless, you're definitely not too late to add your dry hops today, or later this week.

I brewed on the 8th...tranferred to secondary on the 14th
 
Sorry pfish, I obviously didn't do the date math very well! Regardless, yes, you're fine to add dry hops now although, since active fermentation has ended and most of the yeast is out of the beer, flavor stability will probably only last for three months or so.
 
no problem...thanks for the feedback...i think my plan is to dry hop in the next day or so and then bottle around the 5th of Feb. Then let condition for 2 weeks and drink
 
Back
Top