Second batch -overshot the efficiency!

Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum

Help Support Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum:


Well-Known Member
Jan 3, 2008
Reaction score
SWMBO decided to go visit her grandma so I figured I'd do my second AG ever today (actually second batch ever). I'm brewing in my apartment and I've (almost)put together a stowable, ultra small footprint 5-6 gl RIMS rig. It's electric and for this session I decided to try out the new PID controller I've designed for the RIMS.

This time I also did my own crush. I had saved some "pro-crushed" malt from the first batch and I used that as a reference to dial in the cheapo Porkert mill I picked up last week. It turned out to be farily easy to dial in the mill to get a crush that was almost indistinguishable from the reference.

I like to pretend I'm a a daredevil so I took a deep breath and scaled grainbill for 80% efficiency.:cross:

I fired up the RIMS and I used a reference thermometer to check how the controller was doing. The PID thermocouple and the reference did not agree at all (good thing I have ready access to a $50.000 thermal camera to settle the argument...:cool:).

I mashed for 60 minutes and sparged for about 20 minutes. A "small mishap :( " put about 2-3 litres of wort on the floor and I had to basically abort the sparging to take care of the mess.

Now for the nice part: Even though I did abort the sparge and lost a couple of litres of wort, I managed to get 81% efficiency. Had I not lost the wort on the floor I would have been atleast 85%, and If I had not stopped sparging it would probably been a couple of percent higher :D

This time I'd also armed myself with proper cooling eqipment (it cooled to pitching temp within 10-15 minutes as opposed to 2 hrs for the first batch sitting in a plastic bucket in the bath tub...I guess the taste will suffer from that...). I also managed to remember to add Protafloc (a concentrate of the active components in Irish Moss that I got from my prefered HBS). I guess the Protafloc and the much reduced cooling time really increased the amount of trub because this time I had to siphon the wort into the fermenter because the hop-back I had fitted to the boiler outlet clogged up instantly. Probably will leave hop-back out for the next batch and instead just do whirlpooling and siphoning instead.

All in all I managed to get almost 5 gl of OG 1.070 into the fermenter. This is so much fun!



Supporting Member
HBT Supporter
Feb 19, 2006
Reaction score
Bow, NH
Congrats!!! Exact same thing happened to me last weeked. Awesome Feeling when things turn out better then you'd expected, eh?:mug: