Dried Malt Extract vs. Corn Sugar

[goswell]

I'm brewing using Coopers Extract Kits. I've seen recipes that call for 2-3 pounds of corn sugar or dried malt extract. Which one is better, which one gives the better brew?

 

[Iordz]

DME will make your beer 100% better.
Corn sugar really doesn't add flavor, only boosts alcohol and attenuation rates. DME adds maltiness and flavor.

 

[krispy d]

dme +1!!!!

 

[DeathBrewer]

DME is superior. corn sugar should be used for priming only IMO.

 

[Iordz]

DME is superior. corn sugar should be used for priming only IMO.

Unless, of course, you're making a Belgian Triple.

 

[DeathBrewer]

nah, then use some sugars with some good flavor in them

i'd rather use cane sugar or even brown sugar...i've read of other types of cane and beet sugars i'd like to use in my triples, too. my next dark strong ale will use the belgian candi syrup, which i believe is made with beets.

i despise the taste of corn sugar, and even though it ferments mostly out, i try to avoid using it in my beer. i hate it when you can still taste it a week after bottling when i'm seeing how my brew's coming.

 

[homebrewer_99]

Plus corn sugar can make your beer taste cidery after awhile.

 

[Teddi Brewski]

+1 on the cidery-ness call. I find it gives a noticeable sharp sour cideryness...out of place in most beers and somewhat unpleasant (though not unbearable IMHO)

 

[5 Is Not Enough]

Dextrose (corn sugar) is almost completely fermentable. That means corn sugar = alcohol and almost no flavor.
DME will provide fermentables and flavor. You will get less alcohol per volume from the dme, but you will also leave some malt character, which is pretty important for the beer.
Since you're using Coopers Hopped Canned LME (presumably), you may also want to add a little bit of hops too. It may help balance it. I'd recommend an ounce at 15 mins of boil left, which will add a little aroma, too. Ask your LHBS what kind of hops might complement the kit.
You could also just brew about 3 gallons with the hopped LME and get a real feel for the intended character w/out the "cidery" bite of the corn sugar mentioned above(it was noticeable to me and friends when I started).

 

[sirsloop]

lol... you didn't happen to watch Craig's videos on youtube about brewing did you??!?!?


LME FTW!

 

[Somerville]

dried malt extract will give it body. corn sugar will give it nothing but alcohol. plus, dried malt extract is actually made from barley...a real beer ingredient. corn sugar is for soda.

 

[Shux]

Is DME a direct substitute for corn sugar or cane sugar? Example: 1 lbs of DME will make the same SG as 1 lbs of corn sugar or cane sugar.

 

[natefrog255]

To me using DME would be more expensive than using Cane Sugar or Corn Sugar. I would need to have evidence that it makes a beer "that" much better, either taste or appearance.