Orthobrewsky
Senior Member
I brewed a 3.5 gallon batch of 1.090 barleywine on December 30. 23 days later, I transferred to a 3 gallon better bottle and, with the extra, bottled 3. I usually bottle down to that last little bit which gets air in it, so I mark that one and drink it early. Friday, I had some friends over and we all had a few ounces of that bottle. They had been in my basement closet (with the secondary) with a steady temp. in the upper 50's. It had carbonated to about what I would expect--this was one reason I wanted to check one of the bottles, to confirm a finished fermentation.
Anyway, after a few sips, I realized that it tasted like someone had slipped a stick of butter in there. I had always wondered what diacetyl would really taste like in a beer and if I would recognize it, so now I know.
It raises some concerns about the main batch which is still in the secondary. I fermented in the mid 60's, raising it to upper 60's toward the end. I guess I could take out the stopper and smell it, but I'm not sure it was so noticeable in the nose. My hydrometer sample taken after primary fermentation had no strange flavors and tasted great. I know it's too early to expect a good barleywine, but can this be part of the normal weirdness that mellows out after months?
Anyway, after a few sips, I realized that it tasted like someone had slipped a stick of butter in there. I had always wondered what diacetyl would really taste like in a beer and if I would recognize it, so now I know.
It raises some concerns about the main batch which is still in the secondary. I fermented in the mid 60's, raising it to upper 60's toward the end. I guess I could take out the stopper and smell it, but I'm not sure it was so noticeable in the nose. My hydrometer sample taken after primary fermentation had no strange flavors and tasted great. I know it's too early to expect a good barleywine, but can this be part of the normal weirdness that mellows out after months?