Chocolate or Black malt to colour an ESB?

Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum

Help Support Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

CanadianQuaffer

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 10, 2011
Messages
390
Reaction score
4
Location
Ottawa
Hey everyone,

I need to get a bit more colour into an ESB recipe I came up with using Beersmith and I was wondering if either Black malt or Chocolate malt was better than the other for that task?

I'll be adding 4 oz of said malt to the mash which otherwise contains 9 lbs Maris Otter, 8 oz Crystal and 4 oz Wheat malt.

Thanks!

Nick
 
De-Bittered black or Carafa Special III

Both are dehusked and will impart the color without as much of the roast character.

That would be my suggestion.
 
De-Bittered black or Carafa Special III

Both are dehusked and will impart the color without as much of the roast character.

That would be my suggestion.

OK, I'll have a look for that for future batches, but for now I am stuck with either using Black or Chocolate as that's all I have at hand and brew night is tomorrow night.

Sooooo black or chocolate?
 
Well, dark malts and ESB are not a common thing, but if you can't get the Carafa, add the black malt as a late addition to the mash-about 15 minutes before sparging, you will get a lot of color with very little roastiness.
This is a common technique for Schwarzbier.
4oz seems like a lot for a pale beer like ESB.
Do you not have any darker crystal malts?

Good luck,

Tim
 
I dunno...I used Beersmith for the recipe and without the chocolate/black malt the colour was down by the left of the colour meter, near teh yellow, so I wanted to get it more in the mid range. I kept adding black/chocolate malt until I got the colour inthe middle.
 
Hey everyone,

I need to get a bit more colour into an ESB recipe I came up with using Beersmith and I was wondering if either Black malt or Chocolate malt was better than the other for that task?

I'll be adding 4 oz of said malt to the mash which otherwise contains 9 lbs Maris Otter, 8 oz Crystal and 4 oz Wheat malt.

Thanks!

Nick

Four ounces is way too much IMO. That's going to skew the beer towards a brownish tinge. An ounce or so will do the trick, assuming you already have some crystal malt in the bill, making the color similar to Fuller's ESB with a deep copper/amber tone. Chocolate would be my choice between the two or as was mentioned earlier German Carafa malt.
 
8oz of WHAT crystal malt?? 20L? 60L? 120L??

You can also do a little kettle caramelization to get the color a bit darker, IF you really want to. IMO, that's better than adding black malt. A small hit of chocolate MIGHT be ok, but I do agree it's out of place in an ESB.

Also, what's the reason for adding wheat malt?

Also, the color indicated by BeerSmith could be more than a bit lighter than you'll actually get for the batch.
 
The Crystal is 60L and the wheat is for head retention.

I thought the chocolat/black malt would be ok...I've heard that Double Dragon Welsh Ale (a best bitter) has a touch of chocolate malt in it.
 
A brewer at Otter Brewery in the UK told me they use a fraction of a percent of chocolate malt to hit color targets. For my premium bitter, I used one ounce chocolate to get a lovely 12-13 srm.

The first batch had two ounces. That was too much, and the sucker bordered on brown.
 
Assuming you're making a 5 gallon batch (amount into primary) you should get a SRM of about 7.0 with the MO and .5# of Crystal 60L... IMO, you shouldn't need wheat malt for head retention. IF you REALLY want more/better head, add a small amount of carapils/carafoam (like 1/4 to 1/2 pound) to the recipe.

Also, 'a touch of chocolate malt' could be any amount. It could be equal to 1/2oz per 5 gallon batch. Without a reference recipe (that's a proven match for the original) it's rather difficult to say.

I did a Maris Otter SMaSH 3 weeks ago, kegged it on Saturday. With 1/2# of crystal MO in the batch (55L) the color was amazing. The flavor was even better (the hydrometer sample). I can barely wait to get it carbonated and start pouring pints. :rockin:
Moral of that story is to not always focus on what SRM the software indicates for the recipe.

Oh, and which version of BeerSmith are you running?? I'm on the very latest release (fully updated). I've noticed that they've improved the formulas that run it over the updates (as well as with v2.0)... If you're running an older version, or yours doesn't have the latest update/patch applied, I'd update it.
 
My version of Beersmith is the latest update of v2.

OK, so I've lowered the chocolate down to 1 oz, and yes, it's a 5 gallon batch. Both Beersmith and Tasty Brew are giving my an SRM of 9. Is that in the normal range for an ESB?

Thanks for the help so far guys.
 
BeerSmith lists the SRM range for a recipe when you select the style you want to brew to. An ESB ranges from 6-18 SRM... IMO, you're better off keeping the flavors of an ESB clean. I'd go more simple for the grist, and select a solid yeast. That will give you flavors to enhance the brew too.
 
I add about 1/10 lb of black malt or roasted barley to get colour. More than that will take the colour into the deep red range and you'll get the roasted flavour much more. Kind of a dry roasted quality which I like, but not everyone might.

I don't like chocoltae malt much at all and use it very sparingly.
 
I use pale chocolate for color adjustment and have no problems or associated flavors with such small amounts. Again, 1/10th lb is perfectly fine.
 
Back
Top