Thanks for all of the comments and suggestions. I'm using BrewGR to do my recipe calculations. Plugging in my fermentables (8 lbs 2-Row Malt, 2 lbs Caramel/Crystal 20, 2 lbs Carapils) I got an OG of 1.065. In my previous brew I used the same grains and got an OG of 1.065 on the nose. So...