• Please visit and share your knowledge at our sister communities:
  • If you have not, please join our official Homebrewing Facebook Group!

    Homebrewing Facebook Group

Search results

Homebrew Talk

Help Support Homebrew Talk:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
  1. Silver_Is_Money

    My turn... water report

    I think your Calcium is fine as is. Your SO4 ion is actually 42 ppm. Ward Labs only reports the elemental Sulfur, and their shorthand for this is SO4-S (or the S in SO4). As regards why they do this, Ward's business is to analyze farm water, and farmers care about S, but could care less about...
  2. Silver_Is_Money

    My turn... water report

    Water pH is quite irrelevant with regard to mash pH, but Alkalinity can be very detrimental. It is merely a side consequence of Alkalinity reduction that lowers the water pH. If you sparge you will want to perform this Alkalinity reduction for that water also.
  3. Silver_Is_Money

    My turn... water report

    That level of sodium ions may prove to be flavor positive. A read of some peer reviewed research published by brewing scientists of yore* indicates that many of them targeted 50 ppm Sodium ion in beers as light as Pilsners, and 100 ppm in darker beers. *Yore here means commercial brewers...
  4. Silver_Is_Money

    My turn... water report

    2.7 mL of Lactic Acid added to every 5 gallons will reduce this waters Alkalinity to ~10 mg/L (ppm) and also bring it to ~pH 5.5. And so will 28.5 mL of 10% Phosphoric Acid. And likewise 2.4 grams of anhydrous Citric Acid.
  5. Silver_Is_Money

    Building an unbalanced water profile

    Any merely guessed at (or dreamed of, hoped for, wished for...) "ideal" mineral profile stands an extremely great percentage chance of being out of cation/anion mEq/L balance (ionic charge balance), and therefore of being an impossible dream. And a rather shockingly dangerous one at that (if...
  6. Silver_Is_Money

    Water Profile Question

    I'm not the one to ask regarding the intricate specifics of mineral profiles, as I generally see them as I would voodoo. Or mysticism in general. My guess would be that the +/- bars of indistingushability for minerals approach 50%.
  7. Silver_Is_Money

    Water Profile Question

    In my opinion, Mineral additions are a lot like hops additions. Whereby the average person can not blindly distinguish hop IBU levels which vary by roughly about +/- 30 percent. And minerals should be seen within the light of this ballpark rule of thumb guidance. Only with the caveat that the...
  8. Silver_Is_Money

    Water Profile Question

    Presumably (albeit that I've never personally attempted it) good mash efficiency (as reported by those who have tried it) can be obtained via mashing with (or in) distilled water. This would imply that added Ca++ ion is not a contributor to mash efficiency.
  9. Silver_Is_Money

    Water Profile Question

    NaCl has a molecular weight of ~58.45 Na has a molecular weight of ~23 Cl has a molecular weight of ~35.45 Thus NaCl is ~39.35% by weight Na+ ion. 51 - 10.3 = 40.7 additional mg/L Na+ ion required 5 gallons = 18.927 Liters 40.7 mg/L x 18.927 L = 770.33 mg. of Na+ ion required 770.33 mg Na ÷...
  10. Silver_Is_Money

    The effect of SMB for dichlorination on water profile

    For those wondering, 2.82M HCl (which is also 2.82N, and 2.82 mEq/mL) delivers 100 mg/mL of Cl- ions.
  11. Silver_Is_Money

    The effect of SMB for dichlorination on water profile

    2.082N H2S4 will have an acid strength of 2.082 mEq/mL.
  12. Silver_Is_Money

    The effect of SMB for dichlorination on water profile

    For those who are truly persnickety: A 2.082N solution of H2SO4 should deliver nigh-on precisely 100 mg/mL of SO4-- ion. 694 mL of 3N H2SO4 when made up (diluted) into pure water to a final volume of 1000 mL should yield 1 Liter of 2.082N H2SO4 if I've calculated correctly. As always: Trust...
  13. Silver_Is_Money

    The effect of SMB for dichlorination on water profile

    Of course, in saying this, there are three means of achieving percent here: 1) Volume to Volume 2) Weight to Volume 3) Weight to Weight
  14. Silver_Is_Money

    The effect of SMB for dichlorination on water profile

    For those wondering, 1M (one molar) H2SO4 and 2N (two normal) H2SO4 solutions are the exact same thing.
  15. Silver_Is_Money

    The effect of SMB for dichlorination on water profile

    https://www.thomassci.com/Chemicals/Acids/_/Sulfuric-Acid-20N-Standardized?q=2n%20Sulfuric%20Acid
  16. Silver_Is_Money

    The effect of SMB for dichlorination on water profile

    It's closer to being roughly a 9.3% solution.
  17. Silver_Is_Money

    The effect of SMB for dichlorination on water profile

    After crunching better numbers it turns out that 10 mL of 2N H2SO4 will contribute the following as to SO4-- ion: 10 mL added to 5 gallons of water = 50.75 ppm SO4 10 mL added to 20L of water = 48.03 ppm SO4 Both of these are close enough for all practical purposes to 50 ppm SO4 to just...
  18. Silver_Is_Money

    The effect of SMB for dichlorination on water profile

    Per Wikipedia: That plus lots of negatives involving hazardous decomposition products...
  19. Silver_Is_Money

    The effect of SMB for dichlorination on water profile

    I don't believe that the average Joe/Joesette in the USA can purchase high purity 98% concentrated Sulfuric Acid.
  20. Silver_Is_Money

    The effect of SMB for dichlorination on water profile

    2N Sulfuric Acid should likely be quite purchasable. Buying 1L of 2 Normal H2SO4 (of the highest possible purity) is the best bet hands down from a safety as well as long term storage perspective, and it should last a long time. That plus the ease of assuming ~50 ppm SO4 contributed for every...
Back
Top