Just brewed this 4 weeks ago and it's easily my favorite beer I've ever brewed. 100% chance I'll make this again. Love that I stumbled upon this post from 2007 and decided to give it a shot. Thanks for the great recipe!
Made this a few months ago. Opened a bottle last night to check on it and it was great! Marris Otter is life. I only used 2lbs of beech smoked malt but it's really noticeable. I'll probably use 1lb next time.
Will be interesting to see how it develops over time. I can definitely see this...