The kettle was delivered today by FedEx. It was a retail box and it looked to be in good condition. As the pictures show, it was packaged fairly well and I found no dings or dents. Here is my overall impression so far:
Pros: Seems plenty sturdy for holding 20 gallons. The lid also seems sturdy and lays tight on the kettle. The lid has a small hole in it for venting steam. The lid also has a small piece on the bottom that can be used to hook it to the kettle. The kettle is not quite polished, but doesn't have a rough finish either. Should be easy to clean. The handles are both riveted and spot welded on. I am not worried about them coming off.
Cons: The kettle has these holder welded on the inside for holding the screen. Not too much of an issue though since they are high enough and I don't think the would be much in the way of anything. The only marking on the inside of the kettle is a line showing "Max Fill Line". Since I believe this is mainly for something like crawfish, the marking again is for use of the the screen. The spigot included is useless for brewing. It is a cast spigot and is very rough on the inside.
I am mixed on the threaded tube that is welded on the kettle. On the bright side, they cleaned up the weld quite nicely on the inside. I am not sure what exactly the size of thread they used though. My valve from my Anvil fermenter fit on it fine, but the spout would be pointing up. If I tried any 1/2" npt nipples, they would only go about a half turn. I'm not sure if it would be easier to just put the larger hole there for the element and just eliminate it altogether or maybe I could find just how I could get a valve on there (I'm not as knowledgeable about such things).
Overall impression: For $70, I think it is a great deal. I actually think they could easily sell these as cheap brew kettles if they would omit the strainer, remove the tabs on the inside, mark the inside with lines for gallons, and probably just remove the valve altogether. They could either sell it with no holes or just include a simple ball valve without the weld. In this case though, I believe I can make this work just fine
.