Too much water would cause a high ph. I'm not sure it would have too much to do with efficiency, but might cause some tannin extraction.
You'd get 1.034 from just the extract. I calculated a PM, but forgot to add the 2-row! Oops- so, with about 65% efficiency in the PM you'd expect 1.056, so I assume that's what you were counting on.
Broken Leg Brewery
Giving beer a leg to stand on since 2006