I can't even answer this one...too many great ones.
But Lost Coast is just down the road from me. They make great beer and they definitely have great labels.
Downtown Brown is great. A couple of their other great ones are Great White (Belgian Wit) and Indica(IPA).
They always have "seconds" at the brewery/pub, which are cases that are the first ones through the bottling line, or have crooked labels or whatever. They sell them for $20 a case. Pretty good deal for some world-class beer.
Stop through if you're ever in Eureka!