Did you adjust your recipe to compensate that you weren't brewing 5 gallons? Making a 5 gallon batch with only 2/3 the water seems like it would result in a pretty malty beer.
Primary: Nearly Nirvana Pale Ale
Secondary: Needs cleaning
Kegged: Graff, Web Interaction Wit, Edmund Fitz clone Porter, AHS's Pliny the Elder clone
Bottled: Holiday Ale