I like palmer's recipe but I think Shire folk would use a good amount of adjuncts in their brews. They were farmers and had a lot of stuff to throw in. A pumpkin porter seems like something those trixy hobbits would brew.
Primary: Belgian Wit
Bottled: Arrogant Butthole, Arrogant Butthole on Oak and Chinook, Rebel Red (West Coast Red)
Next: Barley Wine