Here's a picture of my Hopslam-inspired brew. It shows the color comparison fairly well. Mine did turn out just a smidgen darker, but pretty darn close. I didn't use the exact same hops with the exception of Simcoe, Amarillo and Centennial, but it still came out surprisingly close.
My grain bill was as follows:
13# 2-row (81.25%)
1# C20 (6.25%)
2# Honey (12.5%)
I think with your current grain bill you'll be pretty close. If you pitch a lot of yeast and aerate well, you should be able to get it pretty dry with the honey/sugar. I mashed at 152 and fermented on a US-05 yeastcake and got the FG down pretty well.
I ended up a little below 10% but still respectable (1.080-1.010).
I could murder a pint! -Lovejoy