2 Bottles, Same Batch, Why so Different? - Home Brew Forums
Register Now For Free!

Home Brew Forums > Home Brewing Beer > Beginners Beer Brewing Forum > 2 Bottles, Same Batch, Why so Different?

Thread Tools
Old 12-21-2012, 06:11 AM   #1
Jan 2012
Posts: 29

I just (very eagerly) cracked open the first bottle from a batch of Barley Wine i brewed up. I know this style of beer should be aging for quite some time before drinking - this has only been in bottles about 6 weeks, but nonetheless I wanted to try it relatively young. So I popped one open, and to my disappointment, it was completely flat - no carbonation AT ALL, zero head obviously as part of that ... and VERY cloudy. All very odd, I have brewed 25+ batches now and have never had a beer so cloudy or even close. Have never had a beer so flat after 5 weeks either.

Immediately i grabbed another bottle and popped it open. Nice carbonation. Nice head. Clear as any beer I've ever drank.

SO, What gives?!?! I'm submitting this beer for a competition, and now I'm on edge. I've held many bottles up to the light and they are very clear with a slight amount of sediment at the bottom. I held the rest of the 22 from the first bottle up to the light and it's definitely cloudy without much sediment on the bottom at all.

Any ideas? Did i have a bottle not properly sealed perhaps?

Reply With Quote
Old 12-21-2012, 06:27 AM   #2
May 2011
Dallas, Georgia
Posts: 759
Liked 93 Times on 69 Posts

my guess is that the first one was not sealed properly is why it was not carbed

did you refridge both the same amount of time? i know that if you dont cool them long enough it wont settle as well.

i would try another to see about carb and maybe just the first was not sealed properly
King's Court Brewing Co. Est. 2011
"Drink with a divine right"

Reply With Quote
Old 12-21-2012, 06:44 AM   #3
45_70sharps's Avatar
Sep 2012
Raymond, Washington
Posts: 1,807
Liked 172 Times on 141 Posts

Is there any chance all of the bottles want sterile the same?

I'm just kind of reaching here, but if it weren't the only one bottle that was so off I would think infection so possibly an infection from one of the bottles not being as clean?

Having one cap that wasn't sealed well make sense also.
Let's see if I keep this updated!

On tap
Black Butte clone

In secondary
Pumpkin ale

In primary
Honey wit

Up next.. Firestone Union Jack clone

Reply With Quote
Old 12-21-2012, 04:46 PM   #4
Jan 2012
Posts: 29

thanks for the input - will keep tabs on this and try a few more bottles to see how it turned out. won't be able to try them as often as i'd like since this beer needs to age. I'd be real surprised if one of the bottles wasn't cleaned enough - seems like even then it'd still be carbonated just nasty tasting/smelling. I think we're on to something with the bottle not being sealed well enough though

Reply With Quote
Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
First Batch in Bottles!!! Skagdog General Beer Discussion 5 11-27-2011 01:06 PM
ABB bottles; going for a batch rico567 Bottling/Kegging 7 08-27-2011 07:08 PM
1st batch in the bottles OldJack Beginners Beer Brewing Forum 1 02-02-2011 04:40 PM
First Batch In The Bottles OHIOSTEVE Beginners Beer Brewing Forum 9 10-22-2009 01:51 AM
First Batch in Bottles hydra-shock Beginners Beer Brewing Forum 2 04-07-2007 02:09 AM

Forum Jump