Is all grain cheaper than malt? - Home Brew Forums
Register Now For Free!

Home Brew Forums > Home Brewing Beer > Beginners Beer Brewing Forum > Is all grain cheaper than malt?

Thread Tools
Old 12-20-2012, 03:48 AM   #1
Dec 2012
Salt Lake City, Utah
Posts: 762
Liked 39 Times on 28 Posts

I was just introduced to all grain brewing on this site, and all I can say is WOW! this looks coool. what are the bennifits to all grain? is the grain cheaper to buy?

Reply With Quote
Old 12-20-2012, 03:52 AM   #2
May 2012
Wash, DC
Posts: 1,236
Liked 161 Times on 124 Posts

I only do all grain but that's cause I'm fancy. It takes hours more in your brew day and it takes a lot more work, learning, and equipment to do all grain. Still, I won't go back to extract and I'm still learning how to mash after 20 batches or so. Yep, fancy.

Reply With Quote
Old 12-20-2012, 04:00 AM   #3
Runyanka's Avatar
Dec 2008
Providence Village, Texas
Posts: 1,536
Liked 20 Times on 19 Posts

Ingredients, yes. Equipment and time, no
Diverse Haus Brewery

blaster_54738 Likes This 
Reply With Quote
Old 12-20-2012, 04:09 AM   #4
Nov 2012
Posts: 173
Liked 11 Times on 11 Posts

If you only look at the raw costs and if your time is worth more than minimum wage, it's a net loss to go AG. The ability to dial in recipes and to fully realize the craft of brewing is perhaps invaluable though. Also, many recipes aren't quite possible to hit exactly using extract.

Reply With Quote
Old 12-20-2012, 04:11 AM   #5
Oct 2011
Fleetwood, Pa
Posts: 1,124
Liked 152 Times on 107 Posts

For me it's about control.
Plenty of people make great beers with extract (DME or LME), but I like to be able to tailor my beers to my specific taste.
All grain is longer, and has more equipment involved, but if you are like many of us, and really like the "science" of brewing, then all grain is definitely the way to go.
Try some partial mash recipes to get a sense of the process, and most important, read,read,read.
I started all grain with BIAB(brew in a bag) and moved on to a mash tun,grain mill, growing hops,making keggles...ect.
If your really hooked, do it, you won't regret it for a second.
Screw it, Lets brew it

Primary 1- BM's Cream of three crops.
Primary 2- Paleface Scalper
Primary 3- Monks Reward (Kreuzberg)
Kegged - Honey Badger, Heady topper clone 1, Indian Paleface Scalper
Bottled- Skeptical Dog winter Lager, Hell's Belgian, Old Dutch Hiefer Hefe,Aphlewein, Chocolate Thunder porter, Jacked up lantern

Reply With Quote
Old 12-20-2012, 04:13 AM   #6
OCBrewin's Avatar
Jul 2010
Orange County, California
Posts: 253
Liked 21 Times on 17 Posts

On a pound for pound basis, yes I think all grain is much cheaper than buying extracts. Remember, you're basically paying someone else to extract all the potential points from a grain and condense it for you with DME or LME. That being said, once you factor on the never ending purchases and upgrades I don't think that I'll ever be ahead really...

Reply With Quote
Old 12-20-2012, 04:17 AM   #7
jcam91's Avatar
Sep 2012
Posts: 235
Liked 18 Times on 16 Posts

Its cheaper in the end. When you have a grain mill and can buy sacks of grains. But the problem is you pay a lot more upfront for all grain than you do you extract. Also it's pretty hard to screw up an extract batch but I've mashed a couple all grain way too high or way too low and didn't really get the beer I was looking for.
Brew on folks!

Reply With Quote
Old 12-20-2012, 04:17 AM   #8
Stay Rude, Stay Rebel, Stay SHARP
Qhrumphf's Avatar
Apr 2011
Arlington (DC), VA
Posts: 13,504
Liked 3475 Times on 2479 Posts

Originally Posted by gelatin View Post
If you only look at the raw costs and if your time is worth more than minimum wage, it's a net loss to go AG. The ability to dial in recipes and to fully realize the craft of brewing is perhaps invaluable though. Also, many recipes aren't quite possible to hit exactly using extract.
My all-grain batches are cheaper per batch, slightly, than extract. But if I wanted I could cut the costs further. Buying malts in bulk brings substantial savings. Of course, buying hops in bulk and repitching yeast help too, but you can do those with extract.

And yeah, there's certain styles you can't really get perfect with extract. Certain styles requiring various adjuncts (Oatmeal Stout for example) that require mashing to get the full effect. You can get away with steeping them, but there's downsides. However, I'd say there's not a style out there that can't be brewed partial mash. Light lagers would be the hardest, but I'd think if you're really careful you could do it.

For me, it's have precise control over my base malt (I have yet to see, say, a Golden Promise extract, and while you can find Maris Otter or Munich extracts, I can't get them locally and would have to order them online if I wanted them), and more importantly control over fermentability that keep me doing all-grain.
Souring: '14 Brett C Old Ale, '15 Lambic, '14 Lambic, '14 Flemish Red, '15 Flemish Pale, '15 Oud Bruin, '15 Session Kriek
Cellar: '10 Brett B Tripel, '11 Lambic, '13 Brett C English Barleywine, '13 Quadrupel, '13 Sour Stout, '14 Brett C Bitter, '14 Spontaneously Fermented Cider, '15 Wee Heavy, '15 100% Brett B Red, '15 100% Brett L Kriek, '15 Bière de Garde

Reply With Quote
Old 12-20-2012, 05:11 AM   #9
scoundrel's Avatar
Apr 2010
Ellicott City, MD
Posts: 806
Liked 44 Times on 34 Posts

I don't think it takes too much longer, at least if you brew AG with BIAB, plus by going to 10 gallons or more, you cut back the brew time per 5 gallon batch. It is nice to have control and formulate recipes. I still do extract sometimes but only when I need to whip up something for a party for people that don't care much.
My Brewday
Track Your Beer

Starter??? I don't even know her!

Reply With Quote
Old 12-20-2012, 05:37 AM   #10
Apr 2012
Albuquerque, NM
Posts: 50
Liked 2 Times on 1 Posts

What really got me to switch to all-grain was that most of the extract recipes in Brewing Classic Styles called for liquid extract and if I didn't use the whole can, I'd have to store it or plan out my recipes to go through my leftovers.
Currently brewing:
- Primary: Munich Dunkel, Rauchbier, German Pilsner, Mochi Rice Wine
- Secondary: English Barley Wine, Date & Honey Ale, Basic Mead

Reply With Quote
Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
60 lb bulk malt extract cheaper? (5gallon bucket) baflint Extract Brewing 2 08-08-2012 08:06 PM
I would like to make beer out of the cheaper canned malt extracts AlaskaBushBrewer Beginners Beer Brewing Forum 3 03-20-2012 01:33 AM
How is all grain cheaper when... snevey All Grain & Partial Mash Brewing 20 02-27-2010 11:46 PM
I thought All Grain was cheaper??!! cmorgan All Grain & Partial Mash Brewing 59 02-12-2010 02:14 PM
All Grain Not cheaper in comparison by much Superman3278 All Grain & Partial Mash Brewing 27 01-18-2009 01:13 AM

Forum Jump