Judging Mead - Home Brew Forums

Register Now!
Home Brew Forums > Wine, Mead, Cider, Sake & Soda > Mead Forum > Judging Mead

Thread Tools
Old 08-24-2012, 01:44 PM   #1
lemy's Avatar
Sep 2010
West Richland, Washington
Posts: 160
Liked 7 Times on 7 Posts

Hi all,

I am looking for some feedback here because I'm thinking I may have done a bad thing.

I recently judged a smaller homebrew competition (bjcp sanctioned though) and there was nobody to judge the 5 mead entries, so I volunteered. I have only ever had two commercial mead examples (dry and semi-sweet), and found them to be quite pleasant and very characteristic of white wine. As a matter of fact, I would put them up against any white wine. I am a fan!

The problem! The 5 meads I judged were sweet. I have had late harvest wine and ice wine; however, never had sweet mead. The mead was cloyingly sweet and very much like syrup. One person in particular made 3 fruit meads. One was a Pyment and I found it to be very much like Port; however, really really sweet without the tannins and high alcohol balance of a Port. The other two were just sweetness overpowering any nuance or delicate flavor and/or aroma that may exist.

I was honest in my scoring and said they were cloyingly sweet and, I think, angered the fruit mead person in particular...

Am I totally off-base here? Since I have no real knowledge of these styles, because I'm basing my impression off sweet wine I have had in the past. Is fruit mead supposed to be cloyingly sweet or is over the top sweetness a flaw?

I appreciate your input!


Reply With Quote
Old 08-25-2012, 07:58 AM   #2
fatbloke's Avatar
Dec 2006
UK - South Coast.
Posts: 2,699
Liked 182 Times on 167 Posts

The commercial meads I've tasted here have all been cloyingly sweet, measuring in the 1.035-1.040 range when tested, putting them squarely in the "dessert" mead bracket.

You mention your limited experience with meads, so I'd have thought that you could only grade them on how you "enjoyed" them, giving marks accordingly. As long as you backed up your finding, with explanations as to why you graded them like you did and explained any "proper/general" faults you found (slight metallic taste suggesting excessive sulphites etc, stuff like that), then I'd have thought given the circumstances, that'd have been the best judgement that could have been allowed for.......
"What the large print giveth, the small print taketh away". Tom Waits.

Oh, and here's some blog stuff!

Reply With Quote
Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Mead newbie question: how to make a bottle conditioned, sweet, sparkling mead? weirdboy Mead Forum 42 07-08-2016 04:54 AM
Bottling mead - Caps vs Corking mead - either method superior? WinsomeLass Mead Forum 39 03-24-2016 09:58 PM
Stark Raven Mead (burnt honey mead attempt) machinelf Mead Forum 65 09-06-2015 08:47 PM
Mead Judging - Question about sweet traditional mead jezter6 Mead Forum 5 01-20-2014 05:00 PM
Pomegranate Orange pineapple mead! (also known as the oh, I might as well mead.) funkapottomous Mead Forum 3 05-24-2010 05:45 PM

Forum Jump