my first BIAB and All Grain experience - Home Brew Forums
Register Now For Free!

Home Brew Forums > Home Brewing Beer > All Grain & Partial Mash Brewing > my first BIAB and All Grain experience

Thread Tools
Old 07-09-2012, 01:11 PM   #1
May 2011
Millburn, NJ
Posts: 1,385
Liked 126 Times on 96 Posts

Prior to yesterday I had only made extract beers (from Northern Brewer and Midwest Supplies).
I did a stove top Brew in a Bag (BIAB) all grain 5 gallon Kolsch.

(thanks to all the great information on this website, and also BIABrewer and Aussiehomebrewer. I'd never have heard of this, or attempted it without your help.)
I had the grains DOUBLE crushed (crushed twice)

(Background (skip past this to see the brew summary):
My favorite beers are IPAs and I have been disappointed with the 4 IPAs I have brewed from extract. I assume the extract is fresh, but somehow the beer doesn't taste that good to me, though my wife thinks they are ok. I've had other home brewers taste the beers and they thought they were ok, no obvious flaws. I wanted to try all grain to see if there is a difference, but I didn't want to buy all the equipment. Which lead me to stove top BIAB)

Because of the limitations I faced (a stove that does not have powerful burners) I used two 5 gallon pots , plus a bunch of other pots to hold water.

I split the grain into two 5 pound amounts and placed them in tow bags - a Nylon bag from a yard sale and a $8 cotton bag form Bed bath Beyond. I had tested both for their ability to allow water to flow easily, but during actual practice the Nylon bag was a disappointment, as it held wort causing me to spend a few minutes holding it, pressing it, shifting it. I know tight weave can be a problem, but in the test it worked fine.

I used a 1.5 quart / pound ratio. The bags (24 x 36) were too big for the pots so I clipped them to the sides with 4 metal binder clips each.
I heated the water to 162, poured it into the pots, stirred it up with a big plastic spoon. There were no problems with dough balls, but with such a big bag, and it being clipped on (no dunking) it was a bit harder to stir, since there are all sorts of folds. But it seemed to work ok.

I covered them up with a towel and let them sit. Stirring every 15 minutes and adding heat if needed. I did not mash out at 170.
After an hour I lifted the bag, drained it (the cotton bag drained MUCH faster), place the bag on the oven rack over the sink, and pressed down on it. I got a lot of the wort out of the grain.
Then I heated another 12 quarts, and placed each bag in that water at 160, with the heat gradually rising to 170 over a 10-15 minute period.
The traditional BIAB uses all the water in one pot, I was limited by my stove and pot size, so I did this 2 step method.

For BIAB where you have to hold a HOT bag I got a $6 pair of heat resistant neoprene gloves (sorry, i cant find the link). They came in handy!

I did a stove top boil in the 2 pots, using a hop bag.
At the 5 minute mark I added yeast nutrient and whirlflock.
The evaporation rate of the two 5 gallon pots was a bit more than I expected, perhaps 3 quarts during an hour boil. I had planned on 2 quarts each. I squeezed the wort out of the hops bag.

Since I don't have a wort chiller, I placed each pot in the double kitchen sink in water, and replaced the water every 10 minutes, three times. After 45 minutes the pots were no longer warm to the tough, but probably still warm, say 100F.

Then I poured the wort into the fermentor. (hot break included, I'm hoping when I bottle the Whirlfloc will cause it to settle in the Trub)
It turns out I was 2 quarts short 4.5 gallons, as my evaporation rate was higher than expected. So I added in 2 quarts of cold water.
I shook the plastic bucket for 45 seconds.

I used my refractometer and measured the starting gravity - around 13.5 Brix or 1.054 SG. The kit says 1.042 - 1.046 at 70% efficiency. So I seem to have achieved over 80% efficiency, probably due to the double crush.

Then I oxygenated it. Maybe I dont need to shake it first, but I figured that shaking it gets some oxygen in the wort, and then oxygenating it on low for a minute will help get the O2 level to a good level.

I decanted my starter and poured in the yeast. (even if the temperature is 90F, I think thats ok before fermentation). I continued cooling the wort by placing the fermentor in a hefty bag, and into a garbage can that held cold water (water and frozen plastic jugs). I used 2 bags, so the water would not touch the temperature strip (fermometer). It cooled down quickly to 62, which is fine for Kolsch yeast. This was at 3PM
Next morning at 7AM the air log was bubbling away.

This took a fair amount of time, and was a bit stressful, as I would occasionally mis temperatures and have to adjust. The boiling/prep was a few hours, and cleanup and cooling the yeast, and pitching added another hour.
I'd say the brew day was 5 hours (and some stress from messing up the temperatures).

I have a 16 pounds of grain Bourbon Barrel Old Ale (MidWest) to brew in a week or two. I'm a bit worried about using 60% more grain. I'm almost thinking of using three 5 gallon pots.

I can see the benefit of an outside propane burner, a 15 gallon pot (in case I want to brew 10 gallons), and a wort chiller. But before I spend the money, I want to see how this all grain beer tastes.

What are your experiences?

Reply With Quote
Old 07-10-2012, 05:47 PM   #2
Dec 2010
Concord, MA
Posts: 636
Liked 24 Times on 21 Posts

For stovetop BIAB, consider doing half batches so you can do it all in one pot. That is what I do, but you may drink beer faster than I do.

Reply With Quote
Old 07-10-2012, 06:06 PM   #3
Jan 2011
Sierra, Nevada
Posts: 4,039
Liked 440 Times on 351 Posts

Originally Posted by ArcLight View Post
My favorite beers are IPAs and I have been disappointed with the 4 IPAs I have brewed from extract. Which lead me to stove top BIAB)
If you ever need any help in the future troubleshooting a BIAB partial mash or all-grain IPA, shoot me a message. When I brew indoors, my system is similar to what you described in the opener.

I usually mash in one kettle while plain water is slowly coming up to mashout temps around 170-ish in the other kettle. I'll dip the grain bag in that 170-ish water after the mash to rinse the grains and sort of act like a sparge, then let the drawstring bag hang from my cabinet and drain into a bowl while the wort is coming up to boiling temps.

I find that my mash temp is maintained pretty well in the course of an hour with only 1 or 2 very minimal temp. adjustments needed. I will pour in hot water from the other kettle to do this rather than turn on the flame under the mash kettle. No need to constantly stir every 15 minutes. Just make sure the grains are wet from the start and revisit 20-30 minutes later for a quick stir and temp. adjustment.

I would try a little better cooling the wort down to 65-ish before adding your yeast. Use ice, and possibly salt in your cold water-bath. Nothing wrong with doing two half batches and later combining them into one carboy for a full batch. I find this method very convenient when brewing indoors.

Reply With Quote
Old 07-10-2012, 07:00 PM   #4
Mar 2012
minneapolis, mn
Posts: 409
Liked 18 Times on 17 Posts

That sounds like a bunch of work... I have a similar setup with similar constrictions so I would second doing the half batches. I do full ones outside but enjoy a BIAB every once in a while and if you have the time you could always just brew more batches and have more variety of beer on hand. Not a bad thing, plus the more you do it the better you get at your process. Either way, congratulation on your allgrain jump.

Reply With Quote
Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Planning My First All-Grain BIAB Experience... mavandeh All Grain & Partial Mash Brewing 13 06-23-2012 04:46 AM
Discrepency in gravity with BIAB, not enough experience to know why Geordan All Grain & Partial Mash Brewing 7 03-15-2012 09:57 PM
Obligatory first AG experience-BIAB Daddymem All Grain & Partial Mash Brewing 15 05-13-2009 07:17 PM
Very bad first all-grain experience... Ryan All Grain & Partial Mash Brewing 12 07-11-2008 04:31 PM
First All-Grain Experience okactuary All Grain & Partial Mash Brewing 3 12-03-2006 03:32 PM

Forum Jump