I'd probably just go with 1.00 ounce of bittering hops (5.5 AAUs) at 60 minutes. That's about what I use in my cream ale recipe, and it's just about right. I don't think 37 IBUs would be correct with only 1.25 ounce of 5.5 AAU hops for an hour, but I don't use that calculator.
Broken Leg Brewery
Giving beer a leg to stand on since 2006