This may have limited use, but I thought I'd share a couple of sites: Labelsbythesheet.com and OnlineLabels.com
(big selection, minimum order)
It's the same company, one site is devoted to very small orders, the other is priced for great big stacks of labels (with good bulk discounts)
They sell a variety of labels, in a variety of paper stocks, including for beer and wine. I use OnlineLabels for my business, and I like to print on their Waterproof polyester (requires laser printer)
I print for liquid bottles, so I know from experience these labels laugh
at spills, heat and cold (though they bond best to room temp surfaces), and peel away in one piece with less residue than your average paper label.
I've been considering picking up some of these labels to basically permanently label my bottles, as they'll hold up decently to washing as long as you keep the wire brush away from the label