
02232011, 11:11 AM

#1

Feb 2008
waterloo, IA
Posts: 167
Liked 4 Times on 4 Posts

will be doing my first all grain soon. and was wondering how to calculate the efficiency of my mash tun, i'm sure it's posted some where on HBT, just don't have alot of time to look for it.



02232011, 12:48 PM

#2

Feb 2011
Matawan, New Jersey
Posts: 29

There are plenty of brew house efficiency calculators out there. They involve taking a pre boil gravity reading and your post boil reading the calculator will take care of the rest. If you want to know the math behind it you can read The Joy of Home Brewing. He gives a great explanation and shows the math.
You can find a good calculator at www.brewersfriend.com



02232011, 02:30 PM

#3

Dec 2010
Louisville, Kentucky
Posts: 31

you are basically comparing the gravity of wort you got with the maximum possible gravity for your grain bill and water volume. You can find the formulas and tables online and in brewing books. Personally I use software (hopville.com and brewtarget) and adjust my efficiency until the calculated OG agrees with my actual OG.



02232011, 05:39 PM

#4

Apr 2007
Huntington Beach
Posts: 9,847
Liked 557 Times on 376 Posts

Efficiency is not a property of your mash tun. It is a result of your mashing.
__________________
Hey, knock that shvt off. We're drinkin' here.



02242011, 06:32 AM

#5

Jan 2009
Boston, MA
Posts: 257
Liked 23 Times on 20 Posts

Here's an example for a simple no sparge brew in a bag recipe.
10 lbs. Pale Malt 2 row with 36 potential gravity points per pound
10 lbs. x 36 potential points per pound = 360 total potential gravity points
6 gallons water for mash
1 gallon water for grain absorbtion ( 0.10 gallons per pound of grain)(10 lbs x 0.10 gal= 1 gal)
5 total gallons preboil wort after the grain bag is removed (measured as accurately as possible)
1.047 measured specific gravity of the pre boil wort ( wort sample cooled to 60 deg then measured)
5 gallons preboil wort x 47 measured gravity points per gallon = 235 total gravity points extracted
235 points exctracted/ 360 points potential = 0.65 x 100 = 65 % efficiency into the boiler
Efficiency into the boiler is a combination of mash efficiency and lauter efficiency.
Don't worry about trying to get the highest efficiency possible,
consistency is much more important. You can always adjust your your grains to bump up your gravity.
Most of the brewers here talk about efficiency into the boiler when they just say efficiency,
some talk about brewhouse efficiency, which includes efficiency losses in the the boil kettle.
I'd recommend BeerSmith, you get a free 21 day trial,
but as you can see with this example it's not that hard to calc it out yourself.
I use both.
Good Luck on your first all grain.
Bob



02242011, 08:50 AM

#6

Feb 2008
waterloo, IA
Posts: 167
Liked 4 Times on 4 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by Buna_Bere
Here's an example for a simple no sparge brew in a bag recipe.
10 lbs. Pale Malt 2 row with 36 potential gravity points per pound
10 lbs. x 36 potential points per pound = 360 total potential gravity points
6 gallons water for mash
1 gallon water for grain absorbtion ( 0.10 gallons per pound of grain)(10 lbs x 0.10 gal= 1 gal)
5 total gallons preboil wort after the grain bag is removed (measured as accurately as possible)
1.047 measured specific gravity of the pre boil wort ( wort sample cooled to 60 deg then measured)
5 gallons preboil wort x 47 measured gravity points per gallon = 235 total gravity points extracted
235 points exctracted/ 360 points potential = 0.65 x 100 = 65 % efficiency into the boiler
Efficiency into the boiler is a combination of mash efficiency and lauter efficiency.
Don't worry about trying to get the highest efficiency possible,
consistency is much more important. You can always adjust your your grains to bump up your gravity.
Most of the brewers here talk about efficiency into the boiler when they just say efficiency,
some talk about brewhouse efficiency, which includes efficiency losses in the the boil kettle.
I'd recommend BeerSmith, you get a free 21 day trial,
but as you can see with this example it's not that hard to calc it out yourself.
I use both.
Good Luck on your first all grain.
Bob

thanks bob, that was just what i wanted to know



02242011, 10:07 AM

#7

Apr 2008
Sebastopol, CA
Posts: 978
Liked 35 Times on 28 Posts

It's simply the amount of sugar you get from a certain amount of grains, compared to the amount of sugar possibly available from those grains. You don't factor the amount of water you used in the calculation. It doesn't matter whether you take gravity readings pre or post boil. Bear in mind that the ppg ratings for your grain might be different than the grains you have actually sitting in front of you.



02242011, 05:00 PM

#8

May 2010
Wixom, Michigan
Posts: 609
Liked 21 Times on 19 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by StMarcos
It's simply the amount of sugar you get from a certain amount of grains, compared to the amount of sugar possibly available from those grains. You don't factor the amount of water you used in the calculation. It doesn't matter whether you take gravity readings pre or post boil. Bear in mind that the ppg ratings for your grain might be different than the grains you have actually sitting in front of you.

I believe you have to take the amount of water into consideration. If I only tell you my gravity is 1.074 how can you tell me how much sugar I got?
__________________
Vir sapit qui pauca loquitur



02242011, 09:24 PM

#9

Apr 2008
Sebastopol, CA
Posts: 978
Liked 35 Times on 28 Posts

What I'm saying is that if you told me the total amount of sugar you got (which obviously isn't given by the sg on its own), and the amount of grain you started with, I could tell you the efficiency. You would have to know the amount of water mixed with that sugar, by either measuring the pre or post boil volume, along with the pre or post boil gravity. Efficiency calculations don't involve mash water used or water to grain ratios, etc.





