I think your percentages are a bit off on recipe #1.
That out of the way, since you have time, why not brew up both? Give away the worse one, and keep the better one for yourself! Haha, or, you could be a sport and do the opposite, considering it's for a wedding and all. If you must choose, I like recipe #1 better. Give it a good English yeast and let the yeast and cinnamon shine through without the more complex grainbill of #2. Given good quality ingredients, oftentimes less is more. I like simple recipes, so that my bias is clear. You may differ, but that's what I'd do.
*Member: The HBT Sweaty Fat Guys Cigar Club