All Novice Judging Panel? - Home Brew Forums

Register Now!
Home Brew Forums > Home Brewing Beer > General Beer Discussion > All Novice Judging Panel?

Reply
 
Thread Tools
Old 11-10-2010, 03:45 AM   #1
Bigscience
 
Bigscience's Avatar
Recipes 
 
Sep 2009
Woodinville, WA
Posts: 626
Liked 29 Times on 26 Posts



Is it possible for a judging panel to be made up of all Novice (non-BJCP) judges? I would think a competition would require at least 1 Recognized Judge in the flight.

The reason I ask is I just got my score sheets back and am disappointed with the results for my American Stout (average 27). All the judges commented on how there were "too much hops". I had the IBUs at 60, within the style, but I can't help but wonder if they'd ever even had this type of stout and realized it's not a Guinness.

I guess what I'm saying is, for my $6 and bottling time, I at least want a real judge with constructive feedback and not a random off the street. Anyone else had lame competition experience you'd like to share?

 
Reply With Quote
Old 11-10-2010, 04:17 AM   #2
Tiber_Brew
It's about the beer.
HBT_LIFETIMESUPPORTER.png
 
Tiber_Brew's Avatar
Recipes 
 
Apr 2010
Upper Peninsula, Michigan
Posts: 2,408
Liked 209 Times on 146 Posts


"Too much hops" doesn't necessarily only apply to IBUs. They could mean flavor and/or aroma, too. Let's have a look at your recipe and briefly describe your process, and see if those judges were in the ballpark.

Sorry to hear about your scores, man. Never, ever worry about what someone else thinks about your homebrew as long as you brew what you want to drink.

TB
__________________
On tap:
1. Imperial Oatmeal Espresso Stout 2. Michigan IPL 3. Kölsch 4. Kentucky Common 5.[Nitrogen] Oat Blonde
Primary:
1. none 2. none 3. none 4. none 5. none 6. none
Secondary:
1. Brett Ale 2. none 3. none 4. none 5. none
Bottled:
About 23 gallons of beer & 3 gallons of mead
Kegged & conditioning:
Rye Barrel aged DIPA, Altbier, Helles x2, Kentucky Common

 
Reply With Quote
Old 11-10-2010, 05:59 AM   #3
Bigscience
 
Bigscience's Avatar
Recipes 
 
Sep 2009
Woodinville, WA
Posts: 626
Liked 29 Times on 26 Posts


I used the following hops in a 1.062 OG, 1.011 FG 12.4 gallon (prechill) 10.8 gallon into the fermentor beer:

2 oz 13.8% Nugget @ 60
1 oz 13.8% Nugget @ 40
1 oz 13.1% Magnum @ 20
2 oz 9.1% Amarillo @5

The grain bill was based on the BCS American Stout with the addition of 2 lb flaked barley.

I just tasted a retention bottle I filled and I think the hops are not "too much". I get more dark chocolate and coffee than the citrus in the aroma and the roastyness comes through in the flavor. When I look at the judging forms they are adding comments right out of the style guideline and listing them like flaws because they don't like them. I don't think the judges really understood this style. I may be cellar blind on this one, I'll grab a few commercial examples to calibrate my palate (I love this kind of homework) and take mine to my next club meeting and get some other opinions as well.

It's funny because I got a 36 from a Certified judge on an Amber that I though was an ok beer and a 31 on an AmRye from a National judge but if I would have had to bet before the competition, I would have put my money on the stout to get a better score than everything else I entered. I guess I can't help but focus on the negative. I did get some quality constructive feedback from a National judge that I'll try to see if I can taste the same flaws as he did. (which was my purpose for entering in the first place)

 
Reply With Quote
Old 11-10-2010, 06:26 AM   #4
Dunerunner
 
Dunerunner's Avatar
Recipes 
 
Jul 2010
Florence, OR
Posts: 795
Liked 15 Times on 14 Posts


I would have thought they would have had a set of the style guidelines at the table. Style 13E, American Stout:

"A hoppy, bitter, strongly roasted Foreigh Style Stout."

IBU's 35-75

2 oz 13.8% Nugget @ 60
1 oz 13.8% Nugget @ 40
1 oz 13.1% Magnum @ 20
2 oz 9.1% Amarillo @5

But, that's a ton of hops. Ran ProMash and it comes up with 84.6 IBU's per your recipe.


What software did you run? Are you BJCP Certified or trained? Not poking, just asking.

 
Reply With Quote
Old 11-10-2010, 06:30 AM   #5
FlyGuy
 
FlyGuy's Avatar
Recipes 
 
Jan 2007
Calgary, Alberta
Posts: 3,605
Liked 178 Times on 51 Posts


BJCP sanctioned competitions do not have to be judged by BJCP recognized judges.

Homebrew competitions are like homebrew shops. Some are good, and some are lacking. Some have great staff that know their $h!t and some have newbies trying to run the show. You have to pick and choose carefully. Never assume that just because you walk into a homebrew shop (or enter a beer competition) that the staff are experts.

Regardless, sorry to hear that you were disappointed with the scores. But did you get any valuable feedback?

 
Reply With Quote
Old 11-10-2010, 02:10 PM   #6
remilard
Recipes 
 
Nov 2008
Kansas City
Posts: 3,654
Liked 43 Times on 41 Posts


Quote:
Originally Posted by Bigscience View Post
Is it possible for a judging panel to be made up of all Novice (non-BJCP) judges? I would think a competition would require at least 1 Recognized Judge in the flight.

The reason I ask is I just got my score sheets back and am disappointed with the results for my American Stout (average 27). All the judges commented on how there were "too much hops". I had the IBUs at 60, within the style, but I can't help but wonder if they'd ever even had this type of stout and realized it's not a Guinness.

I guess what I'm saying is, for my $6 and bottling time, I at least want a real judge with constructive feedback and not a random off the street. Anyone else had lame competition experience you'd like to share?
Do you know all three judges were novices because they indicated that on the score sheets or are you guessing because you don't like what they said? If the former, I would never enter that competition again.

As the other guy said, hoppy doesn't mean bitterness per se and I'll also point out that you don't actually know what the IBUs are. You can't except someone's perception to match what some software guestimated.

 
Reply With Quote
Old 11-10-2010, 02:41 PM   #7
the_bird
10th-Level Beer Nerd
HBT_LIFETIMESUPPORTER.png
 
the_bird's Avatar
Recipes 
 
May 2006
Adams, MA
Posts: 20,908
Liked 529 Times on 425 Posts


To be fair, that *is* a lot of hops. American-style hops certainly can have a fair amount of hop character, but... Speaking personally here, I'm not BGCJ certified but I think I've got a pretty decent idea of styles, I'd still want my American "stout" to be a "stout" first and foremost. Is the roastiness still upfront?

That level of hopping strikes me as potentially more reminiscent of a "Black IPA" or "Cascadian Dark Ale" (whatever you want to call it).

But, everyone's got an opinion, and there's no hard-and-fast rules on how much hopping is too much versus not enough for the style. I wouldn't assume that the judges weren't certified or didn't know what they were doing just because they though this was TOO hoppy for a stout.
__________________
Come join Yankee Ingenuity!

"I'm kind of toasted. But I looked at my watch and it's only 6:30 so I can't stop drinking yet." - Yooper's Bob
"Brown eye finally recovered after the abuse it endured in Ptown last weekend, but it took almost a full week." - Paulie
"no, he just doesn't speak 'stupid'. i, however, am fluent...." - motobrewer
"... I'll go both ways." - Melana

 
Reply With Quote
Old 11-10-2010, 03:05 PM   #8
BrookdaleBrew
Recipes 
 
Nov 2008
Posts: 833
Liked 11 Times on 11 Posts


The Amarillo is probably what killed you. That is a huge late addition for a stout and while I'm sure it's delicious, it probably seems out of style.

 
Reply With Quote
Old 11-10-2010, 03:16 PM   #9
Bigscience
 
Bigscience's Avatar
Recipes 
 
Sep 2009
Woodinville, WA
Posts: 626
Liked 29 Times on 26 Posts


I know (have a strong guess) that they were all Novice for the following reasons:

1 of the 3 checked Novice, the others left the Qualifications section blank
None have a BJCP ID
The forms are not completed correctly
And the overall level of detail in the comments.

To truly answer the IBU question, I'm going to have a buddy test it in his lab.

As for the scores, I'm not necessarily disappointed, my other 4 beers did better than I thought they would. I did get some good feedback on one of them from a real judge. I just wish I didn't waste the time filling bottles to get the same level of comments I got from my brew partner's girl friend, "that's hoppy".

Oh, and I'm not a BJC trained/certified judge. That's pretty much the only reason, for me anyway, to enter a competition is to receive constructive feedback from qualified judges and tune my palate.

 
Reply With Quote
Old 11-10-2010, 04:00 PM   #10
Bigscience
 
Bigscience's Avatar
Recipes 
 
Sep 2009
Woodinville, WA
Posts: 626
Liked 29 Times on 26 Posts


Quote:
Originally Posted by BrookdaleBrew View Post
The Amarillo is probably what killed you. That is a huge late addition for a stout and while I'm sure it's delicious, it probably seems out of style.
This is the type of feedback I would expect from a judge. "Overpowering citrus aroma and flavor dominate this beer while masking the roast. Reduce late hopping additions." That is something I can work with. Thanks.

 
Reply With Quote
Reply
Thread Tools


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Judging insight Catch-22 General Beer Discussion 1 02-24-2010 10:06 PM
Beer Judging Rant jacksonbrown General Beer Discussion 45 12-01-2009 09:32 PM
Judging my 1st competition thedude123 General Beer Discussion 26 10-21-2009 09:52 PM
Beer Judging Competitions Schnitzengiggle General Beer Discussion 5 06-06-2009 04:19 AM
Competitions and judging Dude General Beer Discussion 20 05-21-2006 02:57 PM


Forum Jump