This is not a thread to debate whether or not to do a decoction, etc.... I am brewing a dopplebock on saturday and have all day to brew, so I figured to give a decoction a try.
After doing a ton of research, I am going to keep things simple and do a double decoction. Based on what I have read, I am going to use the following mash schedule:
Dough in at beta amylase rest for 30 min.
Decoct, boil, add to mash, and hit the alpha amylase rest.
After alpah amylase rest, do a thin decoction for mash out and then lauter and sparge.
I was reading www.brewery.org/library/DecoctFAQ.html
and they mention that a beta amylase rest of 145 is good for dry beers (like pils) and around 153 is good for thick beers (bock). It does say that anywhere between these temps is okay. Also, there is a temperature range for the alpha amylast rest.
My question is, how much does the beta and alpha amylase temps matter? Should I shoot for 153 and 167 as the sight recommends, or just try and get somewhere in that range?
I'm guessing it wont make too much of a difference, and I know that the fermentability of the beer is affected more by the lenght the beta amylase rest, not the temperature.
Am i just analyzing this too much? (I tend to do this a lot, its my job!)