I racked the pumpkin ale last night and took another gravity reading. Gravity was at 1.013.
I definitely lost a lot of beer to the pumpkin, here's my 5 gallon better bottle with the beer I was able to siphon off of the mess on the bottom of the fermenter
...and the mess it left...
I'm going to let it sit in the BB for a couple of weeks then condition it in bottles until Halloween.