12 Beers of Christmas 2012!

Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum

Help Support Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Thanks, dgez, Shuznuts, & RedBeard1!

Unfortunately, I have to report that I messed up the carb level on the Tripel. It was really highly carbed & I feared it would turn into a mail/bottle bomb, so I vented it 24 hours before bottling. Apparently that was too much b/c the carb level is low. Sorry :(

On the plus side, the Strong Saison is just about perfect!
 
I'm not posting full reports on the beers right now, because I don't have them in front of me to drink and properly appreciate. Here's what I will say:

I've had three so far, the Caramel Quad, the Fruitcake Old Ale, and the Gingerbread Ale. All three were excellent. My God, the Fruitcake Old Ale was even something that SWMBO would drink, and normally I can only get her to have lambics (hence the reason I made a lambic for this!) and ciders. SHE loved it. I've absolutely loved the three I've had so far, and I plan on enjoying one a night starting tonight until I've had them all.
 
I'll be honest, I was bummed the cherries didn't work out for the dubbel. I'm a fan of real cherries in a brew, not that extract flavoring stuff. But on its own, this is a very nice dubbel. I know its supposed to be a spiced cherry dubbel, but did this beer get the spice treatment without the cherries or is it just a plain dubbel. I get more belgian funk and if it is spiced, it is very subtle, hiding behind that belgian yeast. I think its great color for a dubbel. Thank you very much for sharing.

image-2552788287.jpg
 
Thanks for contributing the lambicky. I think this is a great beer for this time of year. I'm still bumbed Sam Adams took it out of the season mix pack. If it wasn't for replacing it with Chocolate Bock, I would have written Boston Beer Company to complain! To me, of all our 12 beers, the lambicky is most unique to this time of year. They you very much for contributing it this year.

image-443193426.jpg
 
For me, the single biggest wow to this beer was the caramel aspect. I didn't expect a big caramel aspect based on your recipe, but I'll be darned if it isn't caramel in your face. I say that in a good way. Were the sugars carmalized or treated in any way before you added it? Based on the recipe, I expected the sugar contributions to just dry out the beer and leave no major contributing flavor but I was dead wrong. I would love for you to expand on the sugar treatment to obtain that caramel flavor because there are plenty of potential beers that I would like to add that component. Thanks!

image-2926190366.jpg
 
As unique a recipe as a gruit is, I really was expecting something along the lines of the fruitcake old ale. But the method definetly distinguishes itself from other beers. One thing I found interesting was where I got blueberries the most out of the old ale, there wasn't a single addition to the gruit that leaped out the most to me. I found all the contributing flavors to have melded nicely. Great job!

image-4183299326.jpg
 
For those that are considering aging a bottle for next year, I would suggest keeping an eye on the ABV. I am drinking last years along side each of ours. The lower ABV beers were clearly oxidized. And that is being stored for the last year at 55*. My personal suggestion would be not to hold on to anything under 8%. This would include my gingerbread porter with extract that due to crappy efficiency came in under 5%.
 
Abbey Weizen had very nice clarity. A very clean beer with great clarity. When you get to beers this light, it is tougher to hide flaws (which may be why I picked the gingerbread porter :) ) and I fine this beer to be very clean. Although it may be designed to enjoy in the evening during our 12 beers of christmas, I can just as easily see myself enjoying this during the day while watching a bowl game. Great contribution. Thank you!

image-913176205.jpg
 
sfrisby said:
Very nice clarity. A very clean beer with great clarity. When you get to beers this light, it is tougher to hide flaws (which may be why I picked the gingerbread porter :) ) and I fine this beer to be very clean. Although it may be designed to enjoy in the evening during our 12 beers of christmas, I can just as easily see myself enjoying this during the day while watching a bowl game. Great contribution. Thank you!

Which one is that, sfrisby?
 
i received bottles with an "I" on them... which one is this?

also got a package with BD on it - i'm assuming that's the dubbel?
 
Whoops. Original post edited. Thanks.

i was hoping to get over 70% efficiency but it just didn't happen :( still a tad over style in terms of ABV at 5.2% - i'll actually make this beer again anytime of year - doesn't really scream christmas but if you let it chill for a couple of weeks, all the haze goes away and it gets even clearer. i shouldn't have backtracked on making this an imperial abbey weizen. i think it might have stood up to about 7% abv...

thanks for the input guys - i'm gonna sit down here in an hour or so and concentrate on the juniper rye bock... looking forward to it.

again, really jazzed about this project and definitely want in on it next year... i might make the old fruitcake ale anyway next year, i was surprised how much i liked it.
 
The Saffron trippel is very much in the running for the clarity award. What yeast was used for this and was it cold crashed? If so, how long? Really beautiful beer.

In fact, up to the taste, I would guess it was a mead. Remarkable clarity and the aroma was sweet like honey.

I feel like I could learn a lot from this beer. Awesome!

image-1245085480.jpg
 
Sipping on a gruit right now. Love it! Been sampling one every day. My wife was crazy about the fruitcake old ale last night, really digging the juniper rye bock too. Haven't had one that wasn't terrific.

Draygon, has the HGIPA shown up yet? I sent you a pm about it...
 
sfrisby said:
The Saffron trippel is very much in the running for the clarity award. What yeast was used for this and was it cold crashed? If so, how long? Really beautiful beer.

In fact, up to the taste, I would guess it was a mead. Remarkable clarity and the aroma was sweet like honey.

I feel like I could learn a lot from this beer. Awesome!

I used wlp530 for the Tripel. Brewed on 6/18/12, racked to keg with bitter orange peel & 2g saffron threads 7/02/12. Spent 4 months at room temp under CO2 pressure, then cold crashed about 3-4 weeks before I finally managed to bottle & ship. Sometimes I fine my beers with Polyclar Fine, but didn't in this case.

Cheers!
 
For me, the single biggest wow to this beer was the caramel aspect. I didn't expect a big caramel aspect based on your recipe, but I'll be darned if it isn't caramel in your face. I say that in a good way. Were the sugars carmalized or treated in any way before you added it? Based on the recipe, I expected the sugar contributions to just dry out the beer and leave no major contributing flavor but I was dead wrong. I would love for you to expand on the sugar treatment to obtain that caramel flavor because there are plenty of potential beers that I would like to add that component. Thanks!

Was this my quad? If so, yes, the sugars were caramelized before adding to the boil...there's a pound of DME and a pound of cane sugar that get boiled by themselves then added...

How was the carbonation? A prior review seemed to indicate it was weak, and I cracked one open after that and noticed that it wasn't nearly what I was expecting based on the one I had tested a few months ago! I plan on putting what I have left back in a very warm place to see if I can kick up some bottle conditioning again...would recommend that for anyone who plans on aging until next year...
 
the quad i had was perfectly carb'd and fan-freaking-tastic, thank you!

had the juniper rye bock yesterday - not really sure what to say... i'm always impressed by beers from homebrewers that surpass commercial varieties. fantastic aroma, balance, clarity and taste - absolutely loved it. the juniper showed up every once in a while which i thought was perfect. to be frank, a juniper flavored beer scared me because i kept waiting for a pine tree to show up - not the case here, it shows up enough to be noticed every other sip but never overpowers. a brilliantly built beer.

some of the best beers i've had in the last six months are showing up with this project.

going for the gruit tonight (trying to give everything 4-5 days in the fridge before trying)...
 
Im having the Fruitcake Old Ale tonight, the first thing Ill say is...Id pay money for this! Well done! I get a nice "spiced" aroma to it, like that of the fruitcake. The taste is quite good of the fruit you used, and to me I get a bit of a tart finish which I like.

So again, very nicely done! Id like to get this recipe and make this myself.
 
Christmas Gruit

Aroma: Spices, faint alcohol, herbal.

Appearance: Nice amber color, good clarity. Thin head, faded quickly...similar to a champagne pour.

Flavor: I'm getting hints of cinnamon, juniper, and herbs.

Body: Medium, great carbonation.

Overall: This is a very tasty beer. Good finish. I am having this with hors d'oeuvres. The herbalness is complementing the food very well. Need to keep restraint on drinking this too fast, it goes down too easy for such a high ABV. Another phenomenal beer.

I have seen a couple of people say that these are some of the best beers they have had in the last 6 months and I agree. Every beer I've had so far I have said to myself "wow, this is good".
 
just as an update i'll double check, but it looks like i received everything - good work people...

last one i had was the gruit;

aroma: piney, but not hoppy piney - like pine piney, smells warm.

appearance: slightly hazy dark amber... i poured it aggressively and the head built up to about 1/2" and then faded within a few minutes.

flavor: uh, there's a LOT going on in this beer - one thing that surprised me is i couldn't really taste the alcohol - smelled hotter than it tasted and had tons of woody herbal and piney flavors. really nice and i sipped it as slowly as i could (kind of slammed it actually)

body: thick, mouthfilling with a nice lightness - the carb was excellent and really opened the beer up physically as it warmed.

overall: fantastic and i really enjoyed it - it's not a beer i would normally drink, but now i'm thinking about making one! thanks for this, never had anything quite like it and enjoyed every sip!
 
last few days i had a couple different ones;

strong saffron saison;

aroma: smells like blossoming farmland - sweet and spicy with some earthiness

appearance: slightly hazy straw with orange tints - i didn't really let this sit in the fridge very long (just a few days) but i imagine it would clear up quite a bit.

flavor: excellent yeast flavor that doesn't at all carry any warmth from the 10+% abv - although i couldn't pull the saffron out of this, it does have a sweet herbal quality that is excellent. although it's a high abv beer, i could drink this anytime of day.

body: i thought this thing going to have a really full body to it, but in reality is it's perfectly dry and the sweetness it does have is more in flavor than in mouthfeel - excellent beer!

overall: loved it... i'm a huge fan of saisons so this is right up my alley - i'm looking forward to the other two but i'm committed to trying them all before i move onto a repeat session!
 
spiced imperial stout;

aroma: heavy spice and you can smell huge quantities of star anise and warm alcohol... i sipped this bad boy watching a movie late at night with the kids and the aroma said "take your time"

appearance: poured very aggressively and in the dim light of the kitchen but it appeared inky black and didn't get much of a head on it at all - what head there was immediately gone. carbonation was very light, but didn't distract from the beer.

flavor: intense spice and heavy anise... my fiance has tried all of the beers and i've learned that when she says "horrible" i know i'm going to like it... if she ever drinks beer (she doesn't) she goes with a blue moon and an orange slice and can't finish that, lol... what i liked about the spice in this is that the base beer held up to it. you can taste the stout portion for sure... be ready for a spice bomb once you open this up. if you've had this years anchor christmas beer, this reminds me of an imperial version of that.

body: thick, thick, thick, and thick. completely mouth coating without being cloyingly sweet. the body fits the flavor perfectly.

overall: sounds strange, but i was surprised i liked this one as much as i did - not because of the beer, but the last two beers i usually drink are 1) spiced and 2) stouts... again, my beer prejudice has been shattered.

the only one left is the cherry dubel and i'll likely get to that tonight with dinner (ciopinno)...

happy new years everyone!!
 
Drank the Gruit last night. I'd planned to do a write-up but I literally pounded it too quickly. Wow, that was a tasty, well made beer!! :)
 
Sorry for the slow posting of reviews. I've got so much beer to drink from the holidays. I'll try to post the rest of my reviews in the next week!

It's been eye-opening reading your reviews, jtakacs. I'd love to hear from others, too.
 
Now that HBT has developed the itrader section to help ID good traders, I wanted to suggest we go through our list and give back other positive feedback. All the participants (or lack of participants) can be found on page 1 of this thread.
 
Did anyone else save one of each for this Christmas? I forgot all about them until my pipeline started getting low and I started digging deeper and deeper. These are going into the fridge right now! Merry Christmas!

unnamed.jpg
 
I have most of them. I think mine has a lacto infection ( fruitcake ). I will start tasting them tomorrow
 
Tasted a Fruitcake Old ale tonight and you are correct, it got infected...but on the flip side of that, it is a very good sour
 
Back
Top