Pie vs Cake

There is no contest this is a formality.

The single greatest debate of all time. Go PIE!

I convinced the SWMBO to serve Pie at the wedding instead of cake

That's a tough one for me. While nothing is better than a piece of homemade blueberry pie (with locally grown blueberries and crumb topping), I would have a hard time chosing between that and a piece of chocolate cake with chocolate icing in a bowl with milk. (I know, it sounds crazy, but that's the way I like my cake!)

Pie all the way

Although sometimes nothing beats a big slice of moist triple chocolate cake a la mode, pie is just so much more versatile. And for the record I consider cheesecake pie.

But then you have things, delicious things, like cheese "cake" and boston cream "pie". You can't make me choose.

edit: Parker, WTF?

This poll sucks...I like both dammit!!!!!

And what about brownies???

Coastarine said:

But then you have things, delicious things, like cheese "cake" and boston cream "pie". You can't make me choose.

edit: Parker, WTF?

Click to expand...

If it is made in a pie pan, it is pie, if not, it is cake. Therefore:
Cheesecake = pie
Boston Creme Pie = Cake

That sound you just heard is your mind being blown.

Cake or death?!?!?

I like cake, but I want to have it AND eat it too! PIE RULEZ!!!

Parker36 said:

Although sometimes nothing beats a big slice of moist triple chocolate cake a la mode, pie is just so much more versatile. And for the record I consider cheesecake pie.

Click to expand...

I agree cheesecake is pie. My definition is if it has a crust and filling it is a pie. As for the poll, I choose both .

Also, the inclusion of meat voids my vote for pie.

Parker36 said:

If it is made in a pie pan, it is pie, if not, it is cake. Therefore:
Cheesecake = pie
Boston Creme Pie = Cake

That sound you just heard is your mind being blown.

Click to expand...

No sh*t, my WTF was for stealing my idea and using your time-machine to post it just before me, making it appear to everyone else that you had it first.

I'm on to you, McFly...

Cake 4tw!!!! *ducks*

pie all the way. especially cream cheese pie (you can call it cheesecake if you like but I hate to even add the word 'cake' to such a wonderful thing)

Key Lime & Pumpkin V. Flowerless Chocolate Cake (2 V 1).

Think Key Lime and your favorite Pale Ale. OMG

Pie Wins.

thePudwhack said:

Flowerless Chocolate Cake

Click to expand...

ohhhhh, flourless...

Key lime pie can go **** itself, ya I said it. Deal with it

CAKE!

The future MIL makes the best damn raspberry pie I've ever had, but nothing beats the versatility of cake! One layer, two, three, six? They can be as fancy or plain as you like and in sooooooo many flavors.

Unfortunately, dry pie crust and un-moist cake can both choke you to death.

jmulligan said:

CAKE!

The future MIL makes the best damn raspberry pie I've ever had, but nothing beats the versatility of cake! One layer, two, three, six? They can be as fancy or plain as you like and in sooooooo many flavors.

Click to expand...

You think cake is more versatile than pie? What are you smoking? Cakes come in two flavors: Chocolate and not chocolate.

Revvy said:

And what about brownies???

Click to expand...

Too young for my tastes, but whatever does it for you.

Parker36 said:

You think cake is more versatile than pie? What are you smoking?

Click to expand...

I'm not smoking anything, it's in the cake, fool!

Pie is either fruit or no-fruit. Either way, it will be a mushy mess by tomorrow.

jmulligan said:

I'm not smoking anything, it's in the cake, fool!

Pie is either fruit or no-fruit. Either way, it will be a mushy mess by tomorrow.

Click to expand...

Girls, jeesh. Why are they so into cake? My wife won't touch pie (hehe), which means more for me. It is pie season now. Yummmmmmy.
Pie over all. Not even close.

jmulligan said:

I'm not smoking anything, it's in the cake, fool!

Pie is either fruit or no-fruit. Either way, it will be a mushy mess by tomorrow.

Click to expand...

You are clearly forgetting that cheesecakes are actually pies.

Pie Pie PIE!

Although I do respect cake too.

Is pizza pie?

Parker36 said:

Key lime pie can go **** itself, ya I said it. Deal with it

Click to expand...

You're right, I guess it's only good when eaten in Key West.

Coastarine said:

ohhhhh, flourless...

Click to expand...

Well, for your information, I'm only in second grade, and we haven't gotten to that word in the vocabulary book. It's TOO chapters ahead, so THEIR.

Pie.............

pies are most satisfying when thrown in someones face, cakes when eaten. so it depends on how you use them.

shecky said:

Girls, jeesh. Why are they so into cake? My wife won't touch pie (hehe), which means more for me. It is pie season now. Yummmmmmy.
Pie over all. Not even close.

Click to expand...

Dunno but is fact. All that crisco sugary mess on top of a cake sets my gag factor off. Pie!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Pie Rules!

C'mon guys! They make cakes for you too!

The correct answer is pie thanks for playing.

I chose pie but it really depends on the type of pie. I'd much rather have birthday cake for my birthday than pie though.

Also, ice cream cake is not cake. It is ice cream.

The only edible pie is Steak and Kidney pie. I ain't voting for that fruity crap.. If it ain't got animal organs in it I ain't eating it.

Laughing_Gnome said:

The only edible pie is Steak and Kidney pie. I ain't voting for that fruity crap.. If it ain't got animal organs in it I ain't eating it.

Click to expand...

This is why you will never fit in in America. I have a friend from England who spent his first Thanksgiving here last year. Would not stop giving us **** for pumpkin pie until after he tried it. He sings a different tune now.

Pecan pie, end of discussion. Although I do likes me some German chocolate cake! :cross:

wildwest450 said:

Pecan pie, end of discussion. Although I do likes me some German chocolate cake! :cross:

Click to expand...

No, no, sweet potato pecan pie. End of discussion.

Cake is evil, although I hear angel food cake is rather nice.