Dig up or let sit?

Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum

Help Support Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

drez77

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 23, 2007
Messages
450
Reaction score
45
I bought and planted 4 varieties of rhizomes, Cascades, Centennial, Goldings and Chinooks. All but the Cascade were regular sized rhizomes so I took the advice of Vinnie Cilurzo ( TBN podcast) and planted 2 rhizomes per hole. All but the Chinook have started to come up. Would it be better to just sit and wait to see if the Chinook take off or should I dig them up and see it they look ok or dead? Or am i just being a nervous hop grower??

Thanks,

Mike
 
Leave them in the ground! Do not Touch! If you dig them up improperly you will definitely kill them. Based on the fact that you asked this question, you probably will dig them up incorrectly so it is best to just leave them.
 
Let nature do what nature's been doing since before we humans ever walked this planet....GROW THINGS!

Do not dig them up...Do not touch them! Go get a book on gardenning, or brew another batch of beer to take your mind off things...:D

Your job is done for the most part, you dug a hole and planted them...Weed, feed and water if that's what the instructions say to do....but let them do what they know what to do best...
 
That was my original feeling to just leave it alone. Just wanted to verify that was the best plan.

mike
 
I concur, patience. You gain nothing by digging them unless you plan on buying new Rhizomes if the current ones are dead.
 
On a similar note...Would you also recommend not tampering with plants if you've had shoots that grew out, quite well, some over a foot, and then simply died later? I gave them fertilizers and pot ash, etc, watered them regularly but not too much and kept them exposed to light, either natural or a plant bulb for 15 hours a day. Still, my Magnum died and my Cascade snapped at the base and died as a result. I figure if the roots are still growing, there's no point messing with them.
 
How long ago did the shoots die back, and what was the reason with the Magnum? If they haven't reproduced shoots, chances are they are gone. Indoors is tricky, especially watering. And the thing that is bad with watering indoors, is that quite often when a serious problem (like root rot) shows evidence, it is usually too late to intervene. Often with plants just starting out, (especially in pots) it is often better to withhold fertilization until the plant becomes somewhat established and then only lightly. It is mainly growing off of reserved stores until the root system is developed.
 
How long ago did the shoots die back, and what was the reason with the Magnum? If they haven't reproduced shoots, chances are they are gone. Indoors is tricky, especially watering. And the thing that is bad with watering indoors, is that quite often when a serious problem (like root rot) shows evidence, it is usually too late to intervene. Often with plants just starting out, (especially in pots) it is often better to withhold fertilization until the plant becomes somewhat established and then only lightly. It is mainly growing off of reserved stores until the root system is developed.
That stinks. I guess I'll just plant them outside and see what happens. At this point, there isn't much more of a loss that could occur.
 
Here's how I'd proceed, given what we know. Carefully draw back the soil and examine the Rhizome for buds forming. If those are present and it looks healthy, look at the roots, if you see lots of fine hairy rootlets, then the plants are probably OK. If you see neither of these, you can dig a hole and toss them in and just see what happens. What are your short term goals, originally? Did you plan on growing them indoors until transplant time?

When you do this, go slowly and just expose what you need to in order to find out what the status is.

PS. Has it been days or weeks since they died back?
 
My goal was to give the rhizomes a head start until temperatures stabilized over in here in ND. As you know, the Magnum and Cascade have prematurely bit it...possibly. Anyway, I'd say that the Magnum is in the process of dying as we speak, but has pretty much given up the ghost. The Cascade stalk had snapped earlier this week and died a day afterward. I suppose I could carefully root around and peel back the dirt to see what's going on. My fear is that it's probably root rot, since I've seen to their nutritional needs.
 
My suggestion is that in the future, keep them in a ziplock bag in the fridge until you are ready to plant. They can even survive if they get some mold, as long as the Rhizome stays firm and full (it shouldn't look withered or feel pithy/spongy). You want to keep them dormant until you are ready to set them out. An intermediate start is only a good idea with plants that will not make the growing season where you live. Transplant shock can be a challenging thing to mitigate, especially with plants that rely on developing a strong root system for the long haul.
 
To the OP. I didn't see any reference to time. I planted about 5 varieties of hops and everything but my chinooks came up as well. After a month I did dig them up and found them both rotted. Thankfully I have done this in time to get another order in and bury a new type of hop. If it has been a LONG time, I would recommend digging them up to see what is happening.
 
On a similar note...Would you also recommend not tampering with plants if you've had shoots that grew out, quite well, some over a foot, and then simply died later? I gave them fertilizers and pot ash, etc, watered them regularly but not too much and kept them exposed to light, either natural or a plant bulb for 15 hours a day. Still, my Magnum died and my Cascade snapped at the base and died as a result. I figure if the roots are still growing, there's no point messing with them.

Be careful with the potash, and any other fertilizer. You can easily overfertilize and cause damage/death of the plant. A lot of ferts can really change the pH of the soil which can affect nutrient uptake and many are also high in salt. For potted plants I would not even recommend fertilizer (chemical that is), rather mix a good amount of organic material into the soil, such as partially composted materials, leaf matter, aged manure, etc. The environment in a pot is just so different that it doesn't take much to overfertilize. An alternative since you've already constructed the soil for the pot is to use 1:10 diluted plant food such as Tropica Master Grow or another all-in-one fertilizer. By 1:10 I mean whatever they recommend for tsp per gallon, cut that even more.

And on the same page overwatering is VERY easy in a pot due to moisture retention (walls of the pot behave as barriers and so it can keep the soil too wet). The most difficult time is waiting for them to get some roots established because frequent short waterings are required, but I'd ALWAYS suggest erring on the dry side. The other issue with watering a pot is the water TEMPERATURE. In a garden the soil temp will negate quite a temperature swing, but in an enclosed pot its much easier to shock the rhizome/roots. If your ambient temp is 65F, make sure the water you add is close to that. Easiest way is to set out the water you plan to use so it has time to acclimate to the right temperature. This also helps gas off chlorine if you tap has it (note: chloramine will not gas off), and normally increases dissolved oxygen into the water helping to keep the soil aerobic (most tap water has high dissolved CO2 but low O2).

If your one bine broke itself as you said (just lost turgor pressure and collapsed) that could be a sign of overfertilizing (or underwatering). I've started to give my bines some slight support when they are >4". A small twig an inch or two into the soil will give them something to climb on so they can focus on growth rather than rigidity. Once they get longer you can gently "re-train" them onto your larger support.

In my very short stint at hop growing I've noticed an unusual growth rate trend of the bines once trained. It seems like there might be some chemical/tactile signal that a bine produces as if to say, "Hey, I've got a vertical support, gimme more food!". While the other bines continue to grow slightly, the trained one becomes a cruise missle shooting up the support. For example I have a Cascade hop that's single trained bine is 3-4' (FEET) tall, while the other bines from this same plant are only ~6". I have done no pruning, just let them all grow and chose the strongest for training. My other 2 Cascade hops appear to be acting similarly.

So I think ASAP get the hop trained on something, even if you later remove the support from those first couple inches.

Not the greatest picture (and this was a couple weeks ago), but you can see how much taller the trained bine is:

hops2.jpg
 

Latest posts

Back
Top