The HOBBIT......don't bother

Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum

Help Support Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Saw it. First the Dolby 3D sucks - too dark and issues with light reflections on the lens of the glasses. Second, I was in shock at how mangled the story went along... change things for a reason... there was none.

Ok - Smaug was tremendous - finally a dragon from my nightmares - the rest just plain pissed me off. 2 hours and 40 minutes of holding in profanity. Can't get that time back.
 
We did try to warn you you would be disappointed.

I have still yet to see #2. I saw #1 the first weekend, but it pissed me off so much i feel I just want to wait for 2 to come out on DVD or Blue Ray before seeing it. Watch it on Netflix or Amazon.
 
landshark said:
We did try to warn you you would be disappointed.

I have still yet to see #2. I saw #1 the first weekend, but it pissed me off so much i feel I just want to wait for 2 to come out on DVD or Blue Ray before seeing it. Watch it on Netflix or Amazon.
Click to expand...

You did. I just didn't think it would be so horribly bad as it was, and I've been pretty forgiving. So sad.
 
Oh man! What AWESOME movies!!!

Am I the only one who thinks the movies are far better than the books? I mean it was pretty much a children's book after all and I think I was in like sixth grade when I read it. I also remember watching some really bad cartoon story of LOTR in school as well. IMO the movies blow the books away. There, I said it, get over it.
 
headbanger said:
Oh man! What AWESOME movies!!!

Am I the only one who thinks the movies are far better than the books? I mean it was pretty much a children's book after all and I think I was in like sixth grade when I read it. I also remember watching some really bad cartoon story of LOTR in school as well. IMO the movies blow the books away. There, I said it, get over it.
Click to expand...

You are an awesome guy. This proves how the internet is anonymous.

Had I not met you and found out how unique and great you are, I would have said: "NO, there are far more of you who haven't read a book since the 6th grade, and propbably couldn't get past page 1 of Moby Dick, and those are the people they are trying to sell this to."

But that is wrong.

You must be forgiving. I respect that, but I am NOT forgiving.

F**K PJ and crew for botching this, probably the last of many stabs at this wonderful story.

It has been proven that an "epic" story of this type (see: For the love of the King or whatever TF that crap was called) needs more basis than just "Here! We made this up."

It needs a respected base of a classic (or newly classic, see: HP) novel despite trhe fact that 87% of the viewers of the movie will NEVER get past page 1 of the book.

(Did I remember to say: F**K PJ?:() OH! well, one more time is still 50,000 times short of how many times that NEEDS to be stated.
 
Saw it in 3D on Christmas Eve with the wife and MIL. The 3D version was distracting and didn't lend itself well to the overall movie. 2D is definitely the way to go with this movie. Even my wife and MIL thought it the plot was drawn out and love story obnoxious. In particular, they thought the barrel scene where Legolas single handedly takes out an entire company of orcs as their "over-the-top" moment.
 
Same here... and it seems so many of my friends that have never read the book or shown any interest think it is great.

I guess I have become an inflexible dogmatic Tolkien fanatic... I just cannot believe that the Tolkien estate is allowing such license, although the Hobbit rights were much mixed up, where LOTR rights were clearly theirs.
 
Hunger Games was on our list to see, but never got the opp. Should take the kids to see it though.

I thought Frozen would have taken the lead simply due to the vast numbers of kids seeing movies during the break.

I don't know. I just see the barrel sequence and immediately get a taste of bile in my throat. Kind of like when Jar Jar made his appearance in SWEP1. That kind of "WTF is going on here?"

And why the hell could they not replace 5 minutes of barrel ride with a PROPER introduction of the dwarves to Beorn?? The way it was handled in the book was excellent! I think it could have made a great moment of humour.

I can understand the need to condense a few months of travel down to a few days or so. So the whole movie journey took less time than the party's stay at Beorn's house. And they didn't even touch upon the dwarf who got his toe in the stream in Mirkwood and fell asleep!
 
Homercidal said:
Hunger Games was on our list to see, but never got the opp. Should take the kids to see it though.

I thought Frozen would have taken the lead simply due to the vast numbers of kids seeing movies during the break.

I don't know. I just see the barrel sequence and immediately get a taste of bile in my throat. Kind of like when Jar Jar made his appearance in SWEP1. That kind of "WTF is going on here?"

And why the hell could they not replace 5 minutes of barrel ride with a PROPER introduction of the dwarves to Beorn?? The way it was handled in the book was excellent! I think it could have made a great moment of humour.

I can understand the need to condense a few months of travel down to a few days or so. So the whole movie journey took less time than the party's stay at Beorn's house. And they didn't even touch upon the dwarf who got his toe in the stream in Mirkwood and fell asleep!
Click to expand...

Its worse than I thought....
 
organ said:
There are some angry folks in this thread.
Click to expand...

NEWS FLASH


I guess try to imagine something loved and cherished from your childhood.

Now imagine that thing (Big Bird, Kermit, Barney, whatever) being violently raped, shat on, and then gutted with a rusty axe.

That is what PJ and Hollywood have done to poor Bilbo.

:mug:
 
I watched the first Hobbit movie a while back. Frankly, I cannot remember anything about it aside from what was in the trailers. I don't know if I will watch the other two even after they have been on Netflix for a few years. Peter Jackson is the kind of whore that I don't find intriguing.
 
As I think we have sadly determined, If Hollywood had left PJ to his own devices, we would probably have some better movies. That said, I already hated Hollywood, so SOMEBODY NEW has to be the focus of my hate.

Thanks PJ!
 
This movie was a ridiculous POS cash grab. *spoiler alert* That whole barrel riding scene was a lesson in complete cartoonish ridiculousness. Orcs and Warg riders were written to really be something to fear in all of Tolkein's novels and would rip you a new a-hole for fun. Instead, Jackson interprets them as comic fodder and buffoonery (along with the dwarves and, sadly, the elves) throughout this nightmare. These books were a veiled illustration of the horrors of war, the desperate acts of men and beasts against impossible odds and the lifelong bonds of kinship forged by bloody, gory battle.

Watching Legolas slay hundreds of orcs with a bow (how many arrows does that quiver hold anyway) while surf-riding orc corpses from Mirkwood to Lake Town while only suffering a bloody nose is just warped.
 
Isn't there a grim aspect to being closed up in a barrel and ridden down a river until you are half-drowned, and barely escape with your life? The original had the Dwarves talked into being put in barrels and sent down the river to laketown (Or close to it) before Bilbo (Invisible due to the ring) rode on top. The first opp he got to collect the barrels along a bend at a slow-moving portion of the river, he got them out, and some of them barely survived.

Yes, it's not as exciting as the video game style shoot 'em up PJ dreamed up, but there is a dread that could be built up when not knowing if they would drown or be captured by the Elves (Which play almost ZERO part in the story from then until the near end.)

I would have preferred 2 GOOD movies without the extraneous bullcrap, and some of the original INTERSTING writing left in. Or even MORE of the lore of Middle Earth not found in The Hobbit, but rather from the other sources.

Must be 10 year olds have so much disposable cash to spend on going to the movies. I never knew.
 
aiptasia said:
This movie was a ridiculous POS cash grab. *spoiler alert* That whole barrel riding scene was a lesson in complete cartoonish ridiculousness. Orcs and Warg riders were written to really be something to fear in all of Tolkein's novels and would rip you a new a-hole for fun. Instead, Jackson interprets them as comic fodder and buffoonery (along with the dwarves and, sadly, the elves) throughout this nightmare. These books were a veiled illustration of the horrors of war, the desperate acts of men and beasts against impossible odds and the lifelong bonds of kinship forged by bloody, gory battle.

Watching Legolas slay hundreds of orcs with a bow (how many arrows does that quiver hold anyway) while surf-riding orc corpses from Mirkwood to Lake Town while only suffering a bloody nose is just warped.
Click to expand...

He surfs again? speechless.......just speechless.
 
organ said:
There are some angry folks in this thread.
Click to expand...

I can understand their rage though I don't share it. I remember when I was younger and Jurassic Park: the Lost World came out. I was angry after seeing it. Not that the book was Crichton's best but the movie was such a departure that I hated it. But time has a way of extinguishing the raging fires of fanboyism. So too shall it be in this thread.






I thought the barrel riding scene was awesome. [runs out of thread.]
 
RhodySeth said:
I can understand their rage though I don't share it. I remember when I was younger and Jurassic Park: the Lost World came out. I was angry after seeing it. Not that the book was Crichton's best but the movie was such a departure that I hated it. But time has a way of extinguishing the raging fires of fanboyism. So too shall it be in this thread.






I thought the barrel riding scene was awesome. [runs out of thread.]
Click to expand...

Lol, your comment on "The lost world" is spot on. Preposterous. Far worse than what PJ did to the Hobbit.

The scene where the jeep cherokee is sliding back and forth, getting NO traction.....but is somehow keeping a huge RV that outweighs it by double dangling off a cliff.....utter brain dead hollywood crapola.
 
emjay said:
I wonder what might have been if Del Toro hadn't left and been replaced by Jackson...
Click to expand...

The aforementioned "Pacific Rim" has shaken me, but his touch is evident in "Rise of the Guardians" one of the darkest and best kid christmas movies since The Hogfather.

Devil's Backbone is sheer morbidly dark genius.
 
Homercidal said:
Isn't there a grim aspect to being closed up in a barrel and ridden down a river until you are half-drowned, and barely escape with your life? The original had the Dwarves talked into being put in barrels and sent down the river to laketown (Or close to it) before Bilbo (Invisible due to the ring) rode on top. The first opp he got to collect the barrels along a bend at a slow-moving portion of the river, he got them out, and some of them barely survived.

Yes, it's not as exciting as the video game style shoot 'em up PJ dreamed up, but there is a dread that could be built up when not knowing if they would drown or be captured by the Elves (Which play almost ZERO part in the story from then until the near end.)

I would have preferred 2 GOOD movies without the extraneous bullcrap, and some of the original INTERSTING writing left in. Or even MORE of the lore of Middle Earth not found in The Hobbit, but rather from the other sources.

Must be 10 year olds have so much disposable cash to spend on going to the movies. I never knew.
Click to expand...

Agreed. I had visions of the barrel scene. Have the camera inside of a barrel with the actor, show how little space is in there, see a bit of water leaking into some of them perhaps, hear their breath as they fight off being cold and wet for what, days?

All of the action in the mountain dragged on for WAY too long and was totally preposterous. They dial up a massive plan on the fly including dwarves completing nearly impossible acrobatic feats to bring a giant, long dead forge to life in a matter of minutes to pour a river of gold? What the hell was all of that?

I do have to say I really enjoyed all of the interaction between Bilbo and Smaug though. I don't think it could have been done much better.
 
I'm gonna offer my $0.02

As I've said before, like lotr I treat the hobbit movies differently from the books. I think they succeed in somethings and fail at others. Smaug I think rocked. Everything about that scene rocked. The spider scene I loved. I thought many parts of dol galdur were cool. I really wish more time was spent on Beorn. Felt like that was a big miss.

On the negative I thought basically everything with the elves sucked. That's really all I have to say the elves and the continuity are my complaints. Also SPOILER what the hell was with kingsfoil? Not to mention the weird kili elf thing. Couldn't me more pointless.
 
I wonder if the Kingsfoil bit was supposed to somehow replace the sleepy river incident, while at the same time attempt to force the Elf/Dwarf love affair subplot. Remember when Arwen needed Kingsfoil in the LOTR movie to save Frodo? Dwarves would not know of it, because it's needed for an Elf spell.
 
It was a nefarious and obnoxious connection to Aragorn and his secret knowledge as the human king and Ranger of the North - or as we know them - Masons :). Arwen DIDN'T use kingsfoil in any of the lore, rather the elves had better medicines. Kingsfoil was the human name of the herb, and Aragorn had that top secret grail healing knowledge to use it. The LOTR movie got that bit wrong... but it is minor relative to the rest of the lore.

Remember that the writing was done to enhance the sale-ability of the movie, not to enhance or advance the story relative to the books. I did not expect the 2nd movie to divert to such an extent... and the more arcane and IMO less important Great Battle at the end of the book - will now become an action thriller adventure beyond the scope of the LOTR battle scenes. Expect more surfing elves, decapitations and a grand and drawn out attack of Smaug on Laketown, with a slow motion dying dragon rolling to the bottom of the lake and cursed gems falling from its body.

I do wonder how the dwarves left behind will make it back to the mountain... that was just total BS and an extreme diversion for no effect. On the bright side, they didn't hire J.J. Abrams who would have Spock show up and provide counseling to Frodo (and another cheat) just as the Sith joined the invasion to out evil Sauron and steal the Arkenstone to make the ultimate planet destroying weapon. See what I did there? I need to go puke now, cause it just might happen.
 
Homercidal said:
I wonder if the Kingsfoil bit was supposed to somehow replace the sleepy river incident, while at the same time attempt to force the Elf/Dwarf love affair subplot. Remember when Arwen needed Kingsfoil in the LOTR movie to save Frodo? Dwarves would not know of it, because it's needed for an Elf spell.
Click to expand...

Kingsfoil is a healing herb known by elves and the Dunedain.

But that whole scene was just gut wrenching. I mean Arwen in the movies was also gutwrenching as well. But I digress. As I've said before I treat the movies seperately from the books because to me they're different tales entirely. They follow the same general outline but you can't fit all the material from LOTR into 3 movies. For the Hobbit I like the idea of the expansion but ultimately I think they should have just stuck to 2 movies. Hollywood has this desire to unnecessarily drag out their book based blockbusters, Harry Potter, Twilight and Hunger Games are all stretched out in their last book. Same basic thing happened with the hobbit.

It I was writing the screen play for 2 movies it would go

Start prologue style about the battle where Dain kills Azog
Beginning same as the book.
I'd add some more tension before getting to the Misty Mountains, because face it **** can get boring fast
Misty Mountains
Eagles
Beorn
Walk into Mirkwood end of the first movie with them captured by spiders.

Sprinkle in the Stuff with Dol Galdur in there as well.

Second movie. Open with assault on Dol Galdur, cut mid battle to fight with spiders.
Elves carpture and escape in the barrels. I'm not even 100% opposed to the battle escaping in the barrels, only other way to tell it is bilbo riding the barrels because honestly,showing from the dwarves perspective is boring.
Lake Town
Finish battle at Dol Galdur and Gandalf starting to return to the company
Lonely mountain stuff
Smaug dies
Post Smaug stuff
5 armies
bilbo goes home.

I think that would comfortably first into 2 2-2.5 hour movies with no major boring time.
 
I taped in on an HBO free weekend and finally broke down to watch it. Well, i am watching it now, as i sit here surfing the net and thinking how i really should turn it off. I don't remember the book being anything like this.....
 
I just watched Hobbit 1.0 at my sister's last weekend. Ridiculous fights against overwhelming odds, lots of running, 2 minutes of rest...lather, rinse, repeat. I think there might have been a story buried in there under all the orc corpses, but I lost track.

It's a shame. Martin Freeman is a great Bilbo, the casting is excellent, the sets, the atmosphere of the scenes are perfect for these stories. But it just devolves into a CGI horde slaughter-fest. So much story potential completely frittered away.

I'm definitely not paying to see Hobbit 2.0 in a theater. Maybe when it shows up at my sister's house I'll watch it, but I'm not in a rush.
 
There were some posts before about South Park, but not mentioning this one. Semi-related note, and is hilarious.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Watched the Rankins/Bass version (with audio fixed) with my niece & nephew recently. There was much more Tolkien present in that one than the PJ version. Given their limitations, they did a better job.
 

Similar threads

Revvy
RIP Ray Bradbury.
Replies
8
Views
882
Dynachrome
Dynachrome
InkBird 300

Latest posts

Back
Top