@Rodent this is really close to how I made this batch with a few exceptions. I don’t add butter, though it sounds good, and I used potato water (just the water discarded from boiling potatoes yes salt was added, but we can adjust the other salt if needed)
Homemade English Muffins Recipe - Tasting Table Honey instead of sugar, not that it matters much it’s just what was close when I mixed the dough.
I have formed the muffins by hand, but I recommend spreading the dough out by hand and using a cutter. (A tuna can with holes punched in the bottom so that the dough isn’t compressed and degassed Is the perfect size.) Let them puff before cooking.
With sourdough
Sourdough English Muffins Recipe
Do whatever works for you, and please show us your results.