floating hopsacks

Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum

Help Support Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

faustmeister

Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2006
Messages
21
Reaction score
0
My hopsacks with loose hops float in the boil. This of course means that a good share of the hops are above the wort. Is this a problem? Ideas?
 
i dont use hopsacks, i just dump the hops in. if you have a false bottom or bazooka screen in you boil kettle it wont matter at all. if you dont then try this. take your hopsack and while you are syphoning into the primary, syphon through the hopsack into a funnel into the primary. it will catch all sediment and aerate the wert really well. before i got a keggle thats what i used to do.
 
It might not be a huge problem if the wort bubbles and moves them around. Your utilization might suffer slightly.

Strictly by using a hopsack you're going to get different (generally lower) utilization than if you didn't. It might not be a serious effect though, and you can still make great beer with it.

Poor utilization however is a non-issue for most hombrewers compared to consistent utilization. If you have to add another ounce it shouldn't kill you.

Taste is the only thing that matters for us. If it tastes good then it doesn't how you get there. We don't have to worry about small percentage increases in costs like commercial brewers. But if you don't get enough bitterness, or the hop flavour doesn't come through the way you want, then you might want to make some changes, or simply add more hops.

In your case, I would focus on making sure the hops are all wet and that the bag is moving around, or that you are stirring.

Cheers
 
Remember also that right above the surface of the wort is the steam that is coming off during the boil. The steam is even hotter than the wort so that will help get the hop goodies in there also as it condenses in the hops and washes back down into the wort.

As Jagg said also sink them and stir them as well when you stir the wort. I imagine you may lose just a tad of utilization, but I bet it's not much. I use hop socks a lot when I brew. It is easier on the clean up.
 
stainless steel metal nuts or bolts...throw them in and the bag will sink.

I've never done this, but if the bag sinks is there any danger of it burning?

Personally I use whole hops and I throw em right in. I then stick a racking cane into the kettle when it's cooled, and syphon off. If you're using pellets that won't work though.
 
I've never done this, but if the bag sinks is there any danger of it burning?

Personally I use whole hops and I throw em right in. I then stick a racking cane into the kettle when it's cooled, and syphon off. If you're using pellets that won't work though.

i havent had issue yet. It still floats a bit- i only use enough to sink it and keep it below the water line. I use 5 gallon paint strainer bags with whole hops and it hasn't melted yet
 
Sometimes I just toss them in, other times I use Straining Bag - Coarse Mesh 18" x 32" from Northern Brewer. I don't much believe in the "lower hop utilization theory" as I don't see any scientific evidence of such. Especially with the size bag I am using the hops are constantly moving in a rolling boil of wort. When I am done with a pound of hops I can raise the bag up and let the wort drain from the hops.

hop%20stopper.jpg
 
It might not be a huge problem if the wort bubbles and moves them around. Your utilization might suffer slightly.

Strictly by using a hopsack you're going to get different (generally lower) utilization than if you didn't. It might not be a serious effect though, and you can still make great beer with it.

Cheers

I don't agree at all that your going to get different utilization than not using one.

I'm using 5 gallon paint strainer bags and those hops roll up and down freely throughout the entire boil. I can't imagine how I'm loosing anything with this method.
 
Mr Shake, I think what was meant by that comment was that when you enclose your hops in a tiny sack (not a paint strainer) you are packing everything together so they don't have the same surface area effected by the beer. So, when using sacks like the kind you have to tie up, you definately lower utilization.

I myself don't worry about it. Too many people I see homebrewing are extremely paranoid about sediment. I toss all my hops right into the boil without a bag. Along with everything else I may be putting in the brew. When I transfer to primary, I dump the entire pot through a SS Strainer into the bucket. I suppose if you're using carboys for a primary it would be a little more difficult. By the time you chill your wort, most of that stuff should be in the bottom of your kettle anyways, so it's not difficult to dump.

Anyways, I find that this aerates my wort extremely well along with removing any sludge. By the time my beer hits my cup, it's crystal clear (I keg).
 
Back
Top