Electric kettle with PID control

Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum

Help Support Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

neo82087

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 27, 2007
Messages
59
Reaction score
0
Location
Chicago
I'm trying to figure out how to wire up a 220v 4500 watt heating element to a PID. The diagram that I'm thinking of following is located here

My concern is that 110v will be running directly to the heating element. I don't know if that would cause a problem or not. Anyone with some electrical ability have any input?

Thanks
 
It wouldn't cause a problem per say but it would be wise choice to either use an additional SSR for the other hot leg or substitute the 2 SSR's for 1 SSRD.
 
How does this look?

2006360416639675744_fs.jpg


My only question now is how to I ensure that the circuit is grounded? What do I ground the connection to on the side of the heating element?

Thanks.
 
To ground the element you have to create a place to attach the ground wire. On my HLT I soldered a piece of copper to attach the ground wire to. Here is another example. http://essersnet.com/php/content.php?viewPage&ID=200 . If you are using a keggle you can attach the ground to the skirt of the keg with a bolt.

mike
 
Several suggestions:
1. Place a 30 amp, double pole switch between the terminal strip and the SSRs. In this manner, you will be able to turn the element off with the flick of a switch. Also, with this switch, two SSRs are not necessary - one will be sufficient.
2. Is your PID rated for 240 VAC? That is how you have it wired.
3. You should move the inline GFI to the powercord end of your system.
4. Ground everything. The kettle, the double pole switch, and the enclosure should all be grounded.
5. You may want to add a switch to your PID.
Lastly, have an electrician or electrical engineer review the project before you plug it in.
Have fun!
 
Do you happen to know where I could find a 30 amp GFI? I have had trouble finding GFIs rated for 240v. The PID I have has a power supply voltage rating of 85~264VAC/50~60Hz.
 
You would have to use a 4 wire system so you could get 120 volts for your temperature controller unless it is rated for 220V but I doubt it is. Doing this will also make it impossible to put the GFCI on the cords line side since the load will not be balanced. If the load is not balanced the GFCI will trip.

We use 20A 220V GFCI's here let me get the info off of it and see if they make a 30A.
Another option is to use a 30A 2 pole GFCI breaker but then you would have to use a transformer or separately power your temperature controller since the load will not be balanced as stated earlier.


I just noticed that the SSR triggers are wired directly to the output of the temperature controller. I know nothing about the specs of the unit you are using but the Watlow units we use are either relay or ssr type so if this is the case you would also need a DC supply if they use a DC input or you would need to grab 120V if they use an AC input.

Posting model numbers would really help.....


Edit:
The only high power GFCI's that I found by the manufacturer that we use are designed to protect equipment and not persons...sorry
 
It appears that the controller you picked has a 12VDC output so it will work as you intended.

You could parallel two 1500W 120V heaters very easily and you still will be looking at a 30A circuit. Will that setup give you enough heating power???
 
I am using a similar controller and heating element circuit in my RIMS system. I operate the 4500 watt 240 VAC element on 120 VAC.

I think that this gives me the heat output I need because I am only heating 2-3 gallons of mash liquor and recirculating it though the mash at relatively low mashing temperatures.

One side of the element is wired to the system neutral. The 120 VAC side of the element is switched through a SSR. It is unnecessary to use two SSRs for switching the current to the element. One SSR will switch all the current to the element.

I use a 20 GFCI for circuit protection on my system. BTW it is possible to purchase GFCI circuit breakers that protect the whole circuit from your breaker panel. I believe they are a little pricey, however.

Not sure how you plan to use your kettle but if your were planning to heat a large volume of liquid to higher temperatures, you may want to use 240VAC to give you the full power output of the element.

If powering the element with 240 VAC, I think I would use two SSRs.

Always bond all metal components in your system to the ground conductor of the line cord to protect yourself from an accidental short between an energized conductor or element and the tank/liquid contents.
 
So your PID can be run on 120 or 240 VAC. With DC output from your PID, your SSR will need to be switched by DC input. You don't need to control both limbs of a 240 VAC circuit. You can use 2 SSRs but it is overkill. See this link from Watlow describing how to wire a resistive load with 240 VAC controlled by SSR:
http://www.watlow.com/literature/prodtechinfo/files/controllers/ssre_c.pdf
I do think it is important to use a manual switch on your heating element - this should be double pole to control both limbs.
I think you would be wise to get a GFI breaker. You can find 50 amp GFI breakers on ebay or at Home Depot for less than $100. I also agree that you should use a 4 wire power cord and the wire should be 10 gauge.
Have fun!
 
You are going to want that heat sink on the SSR as well.

I have done this before with a Watlow controller on an essential oil extraction pot. I stopped because I found that when the cycle time is too long, you can hear the boil stopping and starting, which isn't what I wanted. If you make the cycle time too short, you will find your lights flickering like crazy (and that isn't good for the other electronics in your house either). Also, I think it is illegal to switch power like that off a residential power feed.
 
With a 4 prong 240v cord, what do I do with the neutral wire? How would the diagram that I posted on the previous page differ?
 
neo82087 said:
With a 4 prong 240v cord, what do I do with the neutral wire? How would the diagram that I posted on the previous page differ?

Actually as stevehaun mentioned the temp controller you are using is rated for 240VAC (sorry I missed that and you even said it earlier..LOL) so you wouldn't need to use a 4 wire system only 3 wire so actually the diagram would work just like you have it except for the GFCI which should be a 30A and ideally be on the line side. You would want to use a 30A GFCI breaker (it may actually be cheaper and easier to use a Hot tub disconnect if you are comfortable with wiring and working in you main panel) and you would use 10AWG as stated above.

Also I still recommend using a second SSR since it is always good practice to open all ungrounded current carrying conductors when the load is not on.

If you locate a Hot tub disconnect near were you are using this it could be used as a disconnecting means also.
 
One advantage of having a 4 wire is that you could power your PID with 120 VAC if you wanted to. In addition you could run your pump (presumably 120) off the same terminal strip.
You definitely want to use heat sinks for your ssr(s). They are cheap - I think I paid about $12 each for mine.
I also fused my SSRs. However the fuses cost almost as much as I could buy SSRs on Ebay.
When I run my boil kettle, I use the PID in %power mode (manual override). I simply turned down the cycle time until I no longer noticed the on/off effect on the boil. My lights don't flicker and I am using two 4500 watt elements. I think it may depend on the size of service at your house's load center. My load center has 200 amp service. Older homes often have only 100 amp service and it would not surprise me if it would make your lights flicker if you had 100 amp service..
 
Wow, you must have a wicked grid if you can switch 9000 watts with no effect. Not so lucky here...
 
I've decided to bump the power down to 3000 watts so I can use the 20 amp 240v in-line GFCI instead of installing a GFCI breaker since I do not have access to the master switch in my apartment building. It'll make my brew day a bit longer, but I'd rather have proper safety equipment in place. The one thing that I am a bit confused about now is the 240v plug. I have 4 prong outlet but I am not sure how I would wire up the 2 hot + 1 neutral + 1 ground instead of the 3 prong plug. Is it possible to plug a 3 prong plug into the 4 prong outlet? Just want to make sure I have things right. Thanks to everyone who has been helping.
 
You can run your neutral to the terminal in your enclosure. You would only need to wire to the neutral if you use 120 vac - your PID or pump or indicator lights.
 
I am a little confused by the schematic. I thought the use of an SSR was because most PID's can not handle the current from a heating element.

It looks to me like the PID is powering the element through terminals 9 and 10, so wouldn't the PID be taking the full load from the element still?

Am I not seeing this correctly?

Does this PID have an amp rating commensurate with the load of the heating element?

I only ask because my plan was to use a schematic similar to the Brutus 10. I was not planning on using the PID to route 120v through the SSR to the heating element. The only voltage from the PID I was going to use was the DC to switch the SSR. I was going to essentially route power from the wall, running in/out of the SSR and to the heating element.

Is this not correct?

Thanks for any clarification.

-Dixon
 
dixon72 said:
I am a little confused by the schematic. I thought the use of an SSR was because most PID's can not handle the current from a heating element.

It looks to me like the PID is powering the element through terminals 9 and 10, so wouldn't the PID be taking the full load from the element still?

Am I not seeing this correctly?

Does this PID have an amp rating commensurate with the load of the heating element?

I only ask because my plan was to use a schematic similar to the Brutus 10. I was not planning on using the PID to route 120v through the SSR to the heating element. The only voltage from the PID I was going to use was the DC to switch the SSR. I was going to essentially route power from the wall, running in/out of the SSR and to the heating element.

Is this not correct?

Thanks for any clarification.

-Dixon


The temperature controller is powered via a parallel connection with the elements and terminals 7 and 8 power the SSR triggers. So no the controller is not carrying the heater element load the SSRs are. My only real complaint about the diagram is the wire color coding....
 
It was done in haste :) Thanks for the feedback, I'll keep this thread updated with my progress as I get some time to work on it after the holidays.
 
I see now...I guess I didn't see the input power from the wall to B and C of the bus. Thanks for helping me understand.

-Dixon
 
mr x said:
Also, I think it is illegal to switch power like that off a residential power feed.

Does anyone have any info on this?
Isn't this how switching power supplies work?

S
 
I think that you are over looking the other possible avenues. Hot tubs are wired with GFCI's. Hot tubs as a rule are multi voltage units. 120/250 Volts nominal is the norm. A GFCI by design monitors fault voltage to ground, or stray voltage coming from the grounding conductor not the neutral or the grounded conductor. You could find a 30 amp 2 pole Square D GFCI Breaker and enclosure at Menards or home depot. The cord could then be wired to the enclosure and then you could run a power cord to your apparatus from the enclosure. These enclosures are rated as NEMA R3 witch is weather resistant. They are made to be exposed to the elements. This would protect the whole of the system. To answer the unbalance load question, any 110, 120, or 277v circuit that is one phase to ground is unbalanced by nature. A 208v, 220v or 480v Circuit is a phase to phase voltage and is balanced its nature. As for the PID If you list the manufacture, model, and Cat# I could look at the wiring diagrams and give you some guidance on how to hook it up for your application.
 
scoates said:
Does anyone have any info on this?
Isn't this how switching power supplies work?

S
Yes, and no it is not illegal on residential power or at least the NEC does not forbid it. How ever According to that same NEC unless all of the parts of the system are listed for the intended use or for use with the individual parts of the system. you would be in violation. The way around is to have a EE approve the drawings and UL list the system. This however is not practical for use lowly Home Brewers.
 
Thanks Nies.

I've actually been spending the last few nights wiring up my new kettle.
My controller is based off a LM555 circuit I whipped up for duty cycling (once boiling), a 25A SSR, and is GFI protected with a 30A cord I got on ebay for ~$80 (shipped, to Montreal).

Will post more once it's done..

I'm not going to leave it plugged in (ie, it's non-permanent; I'll plug it into my dryer outlet) so it's less likely I'll get screwed if my house burns down from something unrelated. Wouldn't want Hydro-Quebec goons showing up at my door, though (-:

S
 
scoates said:
Thanks Nies.

I've actually been spending the last few nights wiring up my new kettle.
My controller is based off a LM555 circuit I whipped up for duty cycling (once boiling), a 25A SSR, and is GFI protected with a 30A cord I got on ebay for ~$80 (shipped, to Montreal).

Will post more once it's done..

I'm not going to leave it plugged in (ie, it's non-permanent; I'll plug it into my dryer outlet) so it's less likely I'll get screwed if my house burns down from something unrelated. Wouldn't want Hydro-Quebec goons showing up at my door, though (-:

S
Cool, I am actually in the process of switching from LP to electric myself. I was was thinking the other day that since I am an electrician I should have a brewing system that reflects my roots. That is my story and I am sticking to it. It sounds like you are on the right track. My own opinion is as long as it has built in protection for you, than " let her rip". Enough said. S Nies
 
I've got my controller box all wired up, and I'm just doing some final checks. With the GFCI, will it be a problem not having the neutral connected to anything on the kettle side?
 
Nope. No problem. I just tossed a Marrette on the end of my neutral line. Just don't ground it (the GFCI might not like neutral being grounded).

BTW, my cheap controller works. More details to be posted in the future (-:

S
 
neo82087 said:
I've got my controller box all wired up, and I'm just doing some final checks. With the GFCI, will it be a problem not having the neutral connected to anything on the kettle side?
No, remember that a GFCI only compares amps across the neutral and the ground. If you short the neural to the ground on your kitchen GFCI it will trip. In theory if you do not have a load to neutral a GFCI is useless. Any voltage to ground will fault the circuit tripping the overcurrent protection device ( the breaker). If you do not have a unbalanced load you do not need a GFCI. Any load to neutral is unbalanced (example: 120v or 277v). These are phase to ground loads. 220v is phase to phase and is balanced by nature. If you do not have a load to neutral in your system I would recommend using a fuse block with fast reaction fuses as these are more accurate than a breaker and ultimately safer. When a fuse dies it is dead. The other thing to remember is that GFCI's were only invented to protect people from their own stupidity I.E. dropping the drier in a sink full of water and then reaching to retrieve it. The best way to protect yourself if you are using straight 220v is to ground everything. This creates a grounding plane and insures that if the equipment fails it will cause a fault condition. These measures do not ensure that you will not get shocked the same is true with a GFCI it just lessens the likelihood of of death. I hope this answers your question.
 
slnies said:
No, remember that a GFCI only compares amps across the neutral and the ground. If you short the neural to the ground on your kitchen GFCI it will trip. In theory if you do not have a load to neutral a GFCI is useless. Any voltage to ground will fault the circuit tripping the overcurrent protection device ( the breaker). If you do not have a unbalanced load you do not need a GFCI. Any load to neutral is unbalanced (example: 120v or 277v). These are phase to ground loads. 220v is phase to phase and is balanced by nature. If you do not have a load to neutral in your system I would recommend using a fuse block with fast reaction fuses as these are more accurate than a breaker and ultimately safer. When a fuse dies it is dead. The other thing to remember is that GFCI's were only invented to protect people from their own stupidity I.E. dropping the drier in a sink full of water and then reaching to retrieve it. The best way to protect yourself if you are using straight 220v is to ground everything. This creates a grounding plane and insures that if the equipment fails it will cause a fault condition. These measures do not ensure that you will not get shocked the same is true with a GFCI it just lessens the likelihood of of death. I hope this answers your question.


Sorry but you should really learn how a GFCI operates before you give advice and as far as the balanced and unbalanced load goes, how does that apply to a GFCI.

A GFCI monitors current flow between 2 current carrying conductors, a ground is not even required for it to function.

The only thing that I would agree with here is that you should ground everything.
 
slnies said:
Yes, and no it is not illegal on residential power or at least the NEC does not forbid it. How ever According to that same NEC unless all of the parts of the system are listed for the intended use or for use with the individual parts of the system. you would be in violation. The way around is to have a EE approve the drawings and UL list the system. This however is not practical for use lowly Home Brewers.

That would be covered by individual municipalities.
The NFPA 70 was put in place to protect persons and property and does not cover power quality.


Switching power supplies such as the ones use in computers for residential use must be FCC approved not to mention most if not all switching power supplies are now required to come with power factor correction.
I am not sure if switching a load on and off quickly would pose a problem in a given municipality but I can tell you that it is not the same as a switching power supply.
A switching power supply is a non-linear load which the power company frowns on because of the harmonic currents they create.

If you want more info on this simply look up non-linear loads.
 
wihophead said:
I am not sure if switching a load on and off quickly would pose a problem in a given municipality but I can tell you that it is not the same as a switching power supply.
A switching power supply is a non-linear load which the power company frowns on because of the harmonic currents they create.
In my country, they frown on all short cycle heavy amperage power switching.
 
mr x said:
In my country, they frown on all short cycle heavy amperage power switching.


Yes, I would imagine it would depend heavily on the size of the infrastructure.
I believe Europe was one of the first pushing for PFC on all residential computer power supplies.

Sorry one more thing about GFCIs....I had a little too much to drink last night and forgot one key point.....;)

I will make it short and simple because there are just too many scenarios to cover.
Depending on the size of your over current protection device it will take anywhere from 15 to 50 amperes for quite a few cycles to clear a fault and it only takes 50milliamperes to kill you, a GFCI designed to protect persons will clear at an imbalance of ~5mA for ~2cycles.

A circuit breaker is designed to protect property, a GFCI is designed to protect life.

Also there is a potential for a GFCI to catch a fault before it becomes a dead short or ground fault.....just because a breaker says it clears at 15A does not mean that is the maximum current it will see because it takes several cycles to clear. This is the reason most branch circuit breakers are rated at 10000 amperes RMS symmetrical and mains are rated much higher ~21K amperes RMS symmetrical. A typical home may see current in the excess of 9KA during an event. I work in industry so the risk is much higher, this is why Arc flash is pushed so heavily in our trade.
 
wihophead said:
Sorry but you should really learn how a GFCI operates before you give advice and as far as the balanced and unbalanced load goes, how does that apply to a GFCI.

A GFCI monitors current flow between 2 current carrying conductors, a ground is not even required for it to function.

The only thing that I would agree with here is that you should ground everything.
I hate being wrong. Today i was having a talk with one of our apprentices and he wanted to know more about GFCI's and I said" GFCI's are a comparative circuit device that compares what's going in to what's going out..." and then I went son of a... #*&^!!! so I am sorry for the miss info. I will say that in a 220 application even involving water that a GFCI is not always the best choice. In the case of a brewing system as long as the loads are balanced you should be good, this also means that a motor load of any kind may not work with a GFCI do to how the motor is built in the first place. S.
 
wihophead said:
Yes, I would imagine it would depend heavily on the size of the infrastructure.
I believe Europe was one of the first pushing for PFC on all residential computer power supplies.

Sorry one more thing about GFCIs....I had a little too much to drink last night and forgot one key point.....;)

I will make it short and simple because there are just too many scenarios to cover.
Depending on the size of your over current protection device it will take anywhere from 15 to 50 amperes for quite a few cycles to clear a fault and it only takes 50milliamperes to kill you, a GFCI designed to protect persons will clear at an imbalance of ~5mA for ~2cycles.

A circuit breaker is designed to protect property, a GFCI is designed to protect life.

Also there is a potential for a GFCI to catch a fault before it becomes a dead short or ground fault.....just because a breaker says it clears at 15A does not mean that is the maximum current it will see because it takes several cycles to clear. This is the reason most branch circuit breakers are rated at 10000 amperes RMS symmetrical and mains are rated much higher ~21K amperes RMS symmetrical. A typical home may see current in the excess of 9KA during an event. I work in industry so the risk is much higher, this is why Arc flash is pushed so heavily in our trade.
On that note, you forgot that in a house hold if you do the math you fault rating one the line side is in access of 41k and a breaker is only rated for 10k which means that your property is not protected from the power company unless you fuse. That is why the code now requires coordination of equipment. You are correct about the breakers ability( good example of bad breaker "FPE") and you are correct about arc flash hazard. Most fuses are rated for 100k rms and can be had in ratings as high as 1M. This is also why your typical 1200-3000 amp switch gear is fused. Note that they are gfci protected above 1000 amps or 1000V nominal. This however is not for life protection it is for fire protection. You are also correct about the limits of a GFCI and that is why they are a good idea. One should note that a GFCI is no guarantee of safety unless properly monitored and tested. This goes for all electrical equipment.
 
wihophead said:
That would be covered by individual municipalities.
The NFPA 70 was put in place to protect persons and property and does not cover power quality.


Switching power supplies such as the ones use in computers for residential use must be FCC approved not to mention most if not all switching power supplies are now required to come with power factor correction.
I am not sure if switching a load on and off quickly would pose a problem in a given municipality but I can tell you that it is not the same as a switching power supply.
A switching power supply is a non-linear load which the power company frowns on because of the harmonic currents they create.

If you want more info on this simply look up non-linear loads.
You are talking about electronic power switching which also causes Freq spikes and hysteresis and also plays havoc with the power supply. Note that the power company frowns on anything that can cost them money. Even if power factor correction wasn't required by parts of the code the power company does, and if you don't comply they charge you for it to the tune of 10s of thousands. Should also note that this covers motor loads and transformer loads. Motor loads in abundance usually account for a lag or a lead in power factor Example: 1000hp westinghouse motor.
 
One more thing before this gets to fare out of hand. We are here to provide good advice to a fellow home brewer, the rest of our ramblings are really a debate on the finer points of electrical theory, and code. Points of which we do not have to agree on completely. So for the record i think we should " relax and have a home brew." Charlie P. S.
 
Back
Top