Its none of my business what any of you guys do, but I'd like to express my opinion that using a plain solenoid to control the gas flow to a burner (unattended) makes me very nervous. I'm horrified to see a lot of people doing it.
Yes, I know that a prominent brewer did it. But I feel its only a matter of time before a controller somewhere turns on a solenoid controlling gas (propane or natgas) flow to a burner and it doesn't light. And gas accumulates. And then something does light it and there is an explosion.
Why not use a gas control valve that is made for controlling gas flow to a burner ? Its not that much more expensive and its all set up to do the job properly.
The thing I fear most with manually controlled burners is that the flame gets extinguished after its ignited and running.
This can happen a number of ways.
- gas line gets pinched
- propane tank freezes up
- wind gust
- kettle boil over
The danger is that the gas flow may resume and without an ignition source, raw gas will be emitted. If it accumulates, there is a possibility for an explosion. The gas flow volumes to some of the burners being used on homebrew rigs is very significant. It wouldn't take much to get an accumulation.
A gas control valve that uses a pilot light and a thermocouple is much, much safer. That is why they are used in furnaces and heaters.
With a gas control valve, as soon as anything puts out the pilot light, the gas flow to the burner is shut down. As long as the pilot light stays lit, there is no risk of raw gas being emitted. Very simple, very safe.
Furthermore, some of the solenoids being used for gas control are being used for gases they are not rated for (propane and natgas) and are being used outside of their temperature ranges, especially when very cold propane is being drawn from the tank.
In my mind these practices are asking for trouble and sooner or later will result in trouble.
Safe brewing.
Yes, I know that a prominent brewer did it. But I feel its only a matter of time before a controller somewhere turns on a solenoid controlling gas (propane or natgas) flow to a burner and it doesn't light. And gas accumulates. And then something does light it and there is an explosion.
Why not use a gas control valve that is made for controlling gas flow to a burner ? Its not that much more expensive and its all set up to do the job properly.
The thing I fear most with manually controlled burners is that the flame gets extinguished after its ignited and running.
This can happen a number of ways.
- gas line gets pinched
- propane tank freezes up
- wind gust
- kettle boil over
The danger is that the gas flow may resume and without an ignition source, raw gas will be emitted. If it accumulates, there is a possibility for an explosion. The gas flow volumes to some of the burners being used on homebrew rigs is very significant. It wouldn't take much to get an accumulation.
A gas control valve that uses a pilot light and a thermocouple is much, much safer. That is why they are used in furnaces and heaters.
With a gas control valve, as soon as anything puts out the pilot light, the gas flow to the burner is shut down. As long as the pilot light stays lit, there is no risk of raw gas being emitted. Very simple, very safe.
Furthermore, some of the solenoids being used for gas control are being used for gases they are not rated for (propane and natgas) and are being used outside of their temperature ranges, especially when very cold propane is being drawn from the tank.
In my mind these practices are asking for trouble and sooner or later will result in trouble.
Safe brewing.