idk, are you torn; it seems like it? good to know you are being indecisive.
Thoughts: your ending puncation seems backwards but i would hate to question your knowledge of the subject so we'll leave it as is.
Recipe Suggestion: definitely use some combination of malt, water, hops, and yeast.
*serious* Indian Brown Ale tickles my fancy if i had a choice to brew either one of those right now.