Rinsing with tap water?

Nobody ever said the beer back then was good. But is was better than getting amoebic dissentery

I would disagree. I've never come across any historical account that mentions anything about wine and ales being something that they drank only because the water supply was poor. They loved the stuff! Just like we do today. The Egyptians, Babylonians, Persians, Greeks, etc. all loved their alcohol. Did they have onestep, or even have a clue about fungi and bacteria?

The Porter I have in the secondary - we don't even know how old that is, I'm sure it was great then like it is great now. Anthropologists have noted that most known cultures have some sort of beer like drink that they love. Even most tribal people make beer from starchy food staples found in their area, and they are as proud of their beer as we are of ours. The women in many tribes in Papua New Guinea chew up a starchy potato like root, spit it out into the same container, then let it ferment it for weeks before they kick back and have a nice drink. That's pretty gross if you ask me.

I'm pretty careful about sanitation myself, but I can't help but ask myself "how they did it back then, and why was it so good?".

You make a good point. Actually, a few good points. People love their alcohol. Probably doesn't matter what it tastes like. You get used to the taste and get a buzz. There is a new show, Going Tribal, where this guy goes to visit and live with various tribes. He visited one that made "beer." They loved it, but to him, it was horrible - didn't stop him from drinking it, though.
I've also heard about the chewing and spitting brewing method. That culture loves the stuff, but you couldn't pay me to drink it. So when I say the beer probably wasn't good, I mean by our standards today. I'm sure back then they raved about it

Ya, I saw that "Going Tribal" also. I love that guy - dude he's brave. Maybe that'll be my next brew "Chew and Spit". Nasty.

I just poured some Weisenbock down my gullet, and boy am I relaxed...I think it's time to hit the hay.

Happy brewing!

Cheesefood,

I boil all the water going into my brew.
I have heard of folks using 'straight' bottled water,
but I boil all water, even if it is to be used for rinse water.

J. Knife

A few years ago one of the news shows, 20/20 or 48 hours did a report on bottled water, they found that most bottled waters contained more bacteria than average homes tap water.

As with Rhoobarb I have so far been using bleach water to sanitize, though I then use a vinegar wash to remove the bleach residue, then a normal rinse to get rid of the vinegar flavor. Totally sterile, even sanitized? Nawh... but mostly and I haven't noticed any of my first 4 batches getting infected or anything.

That said, when I move from the apartment into a house I intend to do a boiler setup and start boiling everything. Just can't really fit it in an apartment. <shrugs>

Many dishwashers now get up to 170 degrees F or greater which kills most stuff. If you have an oventhermometer with a remote temp lead you can run the washer with the thermometer inside to see if your's gets hot enough (I don't trust 'manufacturer's specs' because many manufacturers seem to regard 'specs' as goals, not standards).

Heck, even if it gets close that is good enough for me... dang, this would make it easy. I could do a ton of bottles in a washer, yahoo!

kornkob said:

Many dishwashers now get up to 170 degrees F or greater which kills most stuff. If you have an oventhermometer with a remote temp lead you can run the washer with the thermometer inside to see if your's gets hot enough (I don't trust 'manufacturer's specs' because many manufacturers seem to regard 'specs' as goals, not standards).

Click to expand...

The problem with dishwashers, even those few that do get hot enought to sanitize, is that they don't evenly provide water to the entire surface of the interior of the bottles. I've said this many times...home dishwashers, for the most part, do not provide good platforms for adequate sanitization. A few do, to be sure, but the units that are designed specifically to sanitize are almost always commercial units that use pressurized steam. It's very rare to get a pressurized steam line run to a home!

when i used to sanitize with bleach, i used tap water to rinse. this was in the army barracks at fort sill, OK. i never had any problems with any of my beers while i was rinsing with tap water.

smorris said:

FWIW, I have a friend in the health department ... He suggests letting the water run for at least 1-3 minutes to flush the stagnant water from the house lines and line from the main....

Click to expand...

Yeah, the instuctions on my PUR filter advise you to run water for five minutes after installing a new filter and for approx. eight seconds every time you flip the over to use the water filter option.

I'm going to come back in here and see if I can't keep things clear. A dishwasher will sanitize with heat alone. You may or may not have globs of food stuck in your beer bottles from the process, but it won't be harboring any bacteria. Which is to say, sanitized means germ free - clean means you got the gunk off.

What we need is both. We clean our equipment to get the gunk off, then we sanitize it to kill any germs or wild yeasts or spores etc. Some use rinse free sanitizers, which, while drying in the air, are exposing the equipment to airborne contaminants. Some of us rinse with hot tap water and use right away, exposing our equipment to water-borne contaminants. Best might be to rinse with recently boiled water....

Anyhow, none of us are bottling "sterile" - we don't have the conditions. We are making things reasonably sanitary, and letting the alcohol, yeast, CO2 etc take care of the rest.

For what it's worth, I've used the dishwasher to sanitize the bottles on my last few batches. I haven't had any problems - which isn't to say that it's 100% effective - but I'm going to continue relying on it until I think that it's caused a problem.

Just a few general comments. As Sasquatch notes, it is possible to have sterile dirt. So you need to both clean and sanitize.

I use bottled spring water for everything. Our tap water is not bad but there is just no comparison to the spring water. I use "no rinse" disinfectant after washing my bottles in the dishwasher and visually inspecting each, before and after the wash. But I still rinse them with hot tap water after disinfecting. I figure it is a balancing act - I don't entirely trust even "no rinse" solutions to not affect the taste of my beer or to be entirely harmless to the drinkers (although neither concern is probably rationally warranted).

So far, everything has come our just fine.

Well sad to say I've had 4 spoiled batches. The first two at least I believe was attributed to my lack of sanitizing the lids to my buckets. The last batch though I'm just lost on. I did a secondary fermentation in another bucket which was throughly sanitized. During that racking I know the beer was still good. It might have spoiled because my auto-siphon hose touched some unsanitized counter top or kitchen table. Then it sat in the bucket and filled up. However, I can't help to wonder if my well water is so bad that when I rinse my hose or turkey baster, after useing One - Step, that it gets horribly contaminated.

?'s - How many people use buckets to ferment? & Secondary Ferment? I've read a little about them being a bad alternative because of the lids.

- Anyone have spoilage attributed to their well water?

Looking for Cheers,
Paddy

Follow Up Post: I'm thinking I may have thought of another major contributor to bacteria growth in my plastic buckets... Storing my brew tools in them! Like SS spoon, Thermometers, Wort Chiller... All that metal must have scraped the heck out my buckets. I'll have to examine them tonight and see how bad the damage is. SO my advice and question: Don't store your tools in your fermenter. Where does every else keep their hardware?