Same thing happened to me when I was bottling my last batch. One of the two bottle types I used were twist offs. It broke the first time I kept trying to use my capper which I expected after much reading on here, so what I had to do was push down until I felt a good amount of pressure was applied, quarter turn the bottle and cap again, and repeat until you've equally capped the whole bottle. Bottles are now carbonating and they have worked great! You might be pushing too hard, or there could be a defect with your capper but if not, just stop working out muscle man Haha