The GaP (Grocery and Produce) Beer Experiment

Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum

Help Support Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Tenchiro

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jun 24, 2007
Messages
2,972
Reaction score
10
Location
Providence, RI
Using items only found in your local grocery/produce store, attempt to craft as drinkable of a beer as possible. Ciders, wines and mead do not count. Otherwise you are free to use any ingredient you find in the store.

Keep a detailed log to post here along with pics, tasting notes, etc. If people are up for an exchange after everything is said and done we can do that too.

:mug:
 
Ok, so this interests me quite a bit and I'd like some clarification on some rules. First and foremost, what kinda local grocery store are we talking here, I live in a pretty ethnic neighborhood, and they will have stuff that wouldn't be in a normal store, so are we keeping to like Albertsons, Ralphs, Vons, etc? Number two, is it ok to get a beer that has live sediment and get the yeast there and cultivate it into a starter? and three, how strict is the "no juices or honey" thing? are we saying like 50% of the fermentables need to come from grain? what are the exact rules here?
 
Here's a recipe you could try. I made it - once. Definitely an acquired taste.

George Washington's porter recipe:

To Make Small Beer:

Take a large Siffer [Sifter] full of Bran Hops to your Taste.

Boil these 3 hours then strain out 30 Gall[ons] into a cooler put in 3 Gall[ons] Molasses while the Beer is Scalding hot or rather draw the Melasses into the cooler & St[r]ain the Beer on it while boiling Hot.

Let this stand till it is little more than Blood warm then put in a quart of Yeat if the Weather is very Cold cover it over with a Blank[et] & let it Work in the Cooler 24 hours then put it into the Cask - leave the bung open till it is almost don[e] Working - Bottle it that day Week it was Brewed.


The problem here is hops. You can get hops pellets in the more well-stocked organics sections of some stores, or in some health food stores. Otherwise, it'd have to be a selection of some other bittering herb.

Sounds like fun!

(Just don't make me drink any of Washington's Molasses Porter. Yich!)

Bob
 
Ok, so this interests me quite a bit and I'd like some clarification on some rules. First and foremost, what kinda local grocery store are we talking here, I live in a pretty ethnic neighborhood, and they will have stuff that wouldn't be in a normal store, so are we keeping to like Albertsons, Ralphs, Vons, etc? Number two, is it ok to get a beer that has live sediment and get the yeast there and cultivate it into a starter? and three, how strict is the "no juices or honey" thing? are we saying like 50% of the fermentables need to come from grain? what are the exact rules here?

I would think juice is ok as long as you are not making just straight up cider or wine. You could also harvest yeast from a beer, as long as you used something from the grocery store to culture it.

Although in RI you can't get beer from the Grocery store so some people would be at a disadvantage there.
 
In my grocery store they sell bags of whole wheat berries. They are in the 'middle eastern' ethnic food section. These can be malted. I've done that before. You could then mash other starch adjuncts: oatmeal, sweet potatoes, pearl barley, pumpkin...
As far as bittering. I think I'd use chocolate, coffee, or maybe just use citrus and ginger and skip the bittering.
What about using an off the self IPA to bitter a smaller beer?
 
Ok Rules Post!!
#1 Anything from the grocery store can be used
#2 Juice can only be used if its in conjunction with other ingredients, No meads, ciders or wines.
#3 Yeast, Harvesting from a bottle is ok but you have to step it up using things from the store, no dme or dextrose in a starter.
#4 No hops, Alternative bittering agents should be used.!

Come on people lets see some cereal mashing. maybe some vegetable beers?
 
whatever you do dont use wormwood for bittering, I tried that once and it tastes like cough syrup. In some asian stores you can get the mold that converts rice starch into sugar for rice wine, is this cheating?
 
Damn you people. How about we put this bluntly. If it says malt, dont use it. ok to use malted milk balls, powdered malted milk etc etc Just not LME or DME
 
Sure that is cheating. Major grocery, no specialty asian or other grocers. Now if your store has an ethnic section like mine does then your ok to use it.

Tenchiro. Official Rules Post Needed I think
 
If you can find malta goya at your grocery store (usually with the other mexican soda pop) a lot of people use that for yeast starters. (I didn't believe it til I googled it awhile back.)

large_316.jpg


Hmmm...rather than using it for a starter, I wonder if it could be used as a liguid base extract...Maybe boosted with bakers malt extract (like what was shown on the other thread) and maybe some treacle or Lyle's golden syrup....

Hmmm...maybe I will be in on this...(another use for the gathering dust Mr Beer Keg).
 
Good idea revvy. I was just looking for that post about that.

If I recall from my reading last winter, it is lightly hopped...

I'll try to dig up the info....

I wonder how much it would take to boil it into a reduction? I never tried it, but I fugure if it's like soda pop it might already be pretty watery...

By the way...I don't know if anyone realizes it but the kind of "Malt" in malted milk or ovaltine is not the same as a malted barley.

From How to brew...

Brewer's malt is not Malted Milk Ba...ts, Toasted, Roasted and Chocolate Malts.....

Not that it wouldn't be worth trying ovaltine or malted milk balls, it may be nice as a chololate porter or stout base...
 
Here's the info right from Goya Foods.

product0060.jpg


Malta
Malta Goya - A rich, non-alcoholic, nutritious soft drink, brewed from the finest barley and hops. Both regular and light are available in a wide assortment of sizes.
• Malta Regular
• Malta Light

Some info from the wikipedia.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malta_(soft_drink)
 
By the way...I don't know if anyone realizes it but the kind of "Malt" in malted milk or ovaltine is not the same as a malted barley.

Not that it wouldn't be worth trying ovaltine or malted milk balls, it may be nice as a chololate porter or stout base...

Yeah I realized that but I dont know that everyone else has.
I would bet that Goya malta has a gravity like 1.012 maybe a little lighter then that. That would be a hell of a reduction to have to make to get that into a range that would actually produce some alcohol
 
Yeah I realized that but I dont know that everyone else has.
I would bet that Goya malta has a gravity like 1.012 maybe a little lighter then that. That would be a hell of a reduction to have to make to get that into a range that would actually produce some alcohol

I've seen different specific gravities of Malta Goya on different brewing websites...

THis one says;

The drink is a sanitary malt beverage that holds a gravity of about 1.075. I dillute it with distilled water at the rate of 1 12oz bottle to 1 cup of distilled water. This provides you with a starter wort of a 1.040 gravity.

Now I've read elsewhere that it is 1.040...I think the discrepency in gravities is perhaps becasue people don't decant it and let the bubbles die away before they take a reading...

What I can't find anywhere is what the IBU's are...Goya says it is hopped... Probably like 1 or 2 ibus..
 
Really? That heavy of a gravity wow! even at 1.040 you could possibly just use that although that would completely defeat the purpose of this little experiment.
 
I am still unsure of the base i want to use but I am thinking Candied Ginger, Lemon Grass and possibly Orange Peel for the spices.

Also I know you can buy Brewers Yeast in pill form in the vitamin aisle, but are there any live cells in those?
 
Really? That heavy of a gravity wow! even at 1.040 you could possibly just use that although that would completely defeat the purpose of this little experiment.

Yeah...I'm not talking necessarily about using that as the primary wort...But what about doing a sort of bastardized decoction mash of a dark, oat or barley based breakfast cereal?

Instead of water mashing with that?
 
I was thinking along the same lines. Doing a decoction with the goya and whole barley. and water mashing some whole wheat from something.
 
whatever you do dont use wormwood for bittering, I tried that once and it tastes like cough syrup. In some asian stores you can get the mold that converts rice starch into sugar for rice wine, is this cheating?

I used wormwood in my current gruit ale I just bottled, as long as you don't add very much and use other bittering herbs as well it works quite well, it turned out more Yarrow flavored than wormwood, made the beer quite intoxicating from the sample I tried when bottling.
 
You could always make Pruno.:p All kiding aside I'm thinking a wheat of some sort. I'm pretty sure there is flaked wheat in the health food section of my store. Could harvest some yeast from one of the hefes they sell. I'm going to have to think about this some more. Maybe orange peel with the pith for bittering.
 
Goya sounds kinda like cheating if it's used for the primary barley ingrediant, I don't live in wheat country, so there's no whole barley (at least, not at my local market) Another question on the grocery stores, the closest one to me is this mexican market that's the size of your average supermarket, that has LOTS of strange odds and ends, I think I'll be poking around there quite a bit after finals are over (friday), seeing what whole grains are around that I can malt myself for the enzimes, then probably use malt-o-meal or some other grain cereals in a mash with the malted grains. Due to location I think there's going to be a lot of corn in my finished product.

I think the coolest thing about this project is that if everyone used what's locally grown or available you'd come up with beer that's quite regional, instead of everyone having similar recipe with widely available commercial products, each beer would reflect the geography and culture of each individual's brewing location.
 
I think the coolest thing about this project is that if everyone used what's locally grown or available you'd come up with beer that's quite regional, instead of everyone having similar recipe with widely available commercial products, each beer would reflect the geography and culture of each individual's brewing location.

Yes cool thought. My area has alot of wheat but we also have a large muslim population in the area and I was thinking about using cracked wheat, burghul(sp) however its very expensive so I dont know.
 
I wonder if the yeast on the surface of the raisins in raisin bran would be enough to ferment a batch of beer? You could mash the cereal then add the raisins at ptiching time.
 
I wonder if the yeast on the surface of the raisins in raisin bran would be enough to ferment a batch of beer? You could mash the cereal then add the raisins at ptiching time.

That's an interesting though, what about (and this is kinda a long way to go about it) going to the produce section, grab a bunch of fruits, blend 'em up and let them ferment out in different small carboys with the yeasts on the peels. Decide which one's the best, wash the yeast at the bottom, then pitch it into whatever grain-based wort you're using for your final beer, with/without a starter.
 
That's an interesting though, what about (and this is kinda a long way to go about it) going to the produce section, grab a bunch of fruits, blend 'em up and let them ferment out in different small carboys with the yeasts on the peels. Decide which one's the best, wash the yeast at the bottom, then pitch it into whatever grain-based wort you're using for your final beer, with/without a starter.

That would take quite a while. Natural yeast sometimes can start slowly, and will take a while to drop to the bottom and clarify the must.
 
This is pretty darn good preparation for the coming zombiepocalypse.... :D

I still maintain that he who can make some form of potable beverage, after the water system collapses, will be the leader of masses (and get all the nubile chicks.)

We'll know what stuff we need to grab when we're raiding walmart.

:mug:
 
This will most likely turn into some kind of horrible jailhouse/post-apocolyptical, brewed in dark basements and bomb shelters kinda drink. But just like revvy said we will be the only ones with alcohol when the civilized world crashes to an end!!!!!
 
We'll be the snake oil salesmen of the new milenia!!!

We'll go from town to town in our horsedrawn hummers, trading our "magic barley water" for bags of rice and nubile women.

I've even got my label/sign made up :D

Curative_tonic_copy.jpg
 
This will most likely turn into some kind of horrible jailhouse/post-apocolyptical, brewed in dark basements and bomb shelters kinda drink. But just like revvy said we will be the only ones with alcohol when the civilized world crashes to an end!!!!!

I don't konw, besides the yeast problems, I think that some of these could turn out quite good, different most definatly, depending on the process and ingrediants used. can't be any stranger than "Mountain Brew" http://byo.com/recipe/1331.html
 
lol "Cures lack of sexual prowess and wooing of the opposite sex" Perfect@!!!!!!!!!
 
We could all do this!!!!


Originally Posted by RICLARK
put 2 loafs of bread into a trashbag with 2 gallons of water let sit three monthes and then add it to your wort. :rolleyes:
 
I was considering using natural ginger beer (non-alcoholic) as the base fermentable. I also found a couple of brands of malt soda, some are even hopped. It was also suggested that bitters can be used from the mixer section of the supermarket.
 
I have been thinking about this thread all morning when I should be thinking about something else. The issue of the yeast concerns me the most, but keep in mind that bread yeast and top fermenting ale yeast are the same species but prepared differently. Even though, I'm still not sure I'm willing to ferment with bread yeast, so I'm leaning toward the cultivate from a bottle idea. I can see the potential here to make a suprisingly drinkable beer. Hell, if ancient civilizations could make beer that was drinkable (and apparently good to them) the only real thing standing in our way is re-defining "drinkable".

I'm thinking of doing no more than a 2-gallon batch just because this sounds like a hell of alot of fun, and might be a good skill to have in case of an apocalypse.
 
Back
Top